Windermere Club Home Prices, Plat by Plat (2026)
Quick answer: Windermere Club recorded 13 qualified home sales between July 2024 and June 2026, ranging from $870,000 to $3,040,000, with a median of $1,400,000. Five lakefront homes on Lake Crescent and Lake Roberts sold at a median of $1,800,000, about $460 per square foot; eight off-lake homes at $985,000, about $325. Every one of the 147 lots is at least half an acre.
Windermere Club is the gated neighborhood built around the former Windermere Country Club course, with Windermere 34786 addresses in unincorporated Orange County. Our Windermere Club community page has the overview, and our article on what happened to the Windermere Club golf course covers the closed course and the homes that back onto it. The community page does not quote a median price, because a single year brings only a few sales. This article pools two years and breaks them down the way the county records the neighborhood: by plat, by street and by lake. It uses the Florida Department of Revenue's 2026 tax roll and Orange County's parcel and lake maps.
Three plats make up Windermere Club
On the county's records there is no plat called Windermere Club. Its 147 homes sit on three Butler Bay plats:
| Plat | Homes | Streets | Built | Median home | Median lot | Lakefront lots |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butler Bay Unit 2 (Plat Book 13, Page 59) | 27 | Butler Bay Drive N. (20), Crescent Cove Court (7) | 1985 to 2000, median 1989 | 4,640 sq ft | 1.06 acres | 12, on Lake Crescent |
| Butler Bay Unit 3 (Plat Book 18, Page 4, 1986) | 118 | Butler Bay Drive N. (39), Butler Bay Court (37), Lake Roberts Court (22), Lake Crescent Court (20) | 1988 to 2022, median 1991 | 3,599 sq ft | 0.57 acre | 39: 27 on Lake Crescent, 12 on Lake Roberts |
| Butler Bay Unit 3 replat (Plat Book 25, Page 116, 1990) | 2 | Butler Bay Drive N. | 1994 and 1996 | 5,603 sq ft | 0.91 acre | 2, on Lake Crescent |
| Windermere Club | 147 | 5 streets | 1985 to 2022, median 1991 | 3,756 sq ft | 0.61 acre | 53 |
Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll (homes, plat from the legal description, living area, land area, year built), checked October 29, 2026. Lakefront: the lot touches the lake's outline on Orange County GIS hydrology maps or the state-owned lake bottom parcel (11 Lake Crescent lots). Plat years for Unit 3 and the replat from Orange County Property Appraiser instrument numbers, as reported in our golf course article.
Unit 2 is the estate section. All 27 of its lots are an acre or more, the smallest 1.0 acre, and its homes are about 1,000 sq ft larger than Unit 3's. It is also the older plat: its oldest homes date from 1985. Unit 3 is where most of the neighborhood is, on lots of about half an acre to an acre, and every one of its 118 lots is at least half an acre. Across the whole neighborhood, 40 homes have an acre or more, and the county's records list a pool at 143 of the 147.
A fourth Butler Bay plat, Unit 1 on Marquesas Court and Sunbittern Court, has 33 homes inside the Town of Windermere. It shares the Butler Bay name but is not part of Windermere Club, and its sales are not counted here.
What sold, plat by plat and street by street
| Section | Homes | Sales, Jul 2024 to Jun 2026 | Sale prices |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unit 2: Butler Bay Drive N. and Crescent Cove Court | 27 | 2 | $1,400,000 and $1,650,000, both off the lake, on lots of about an acre |
| Unit 3: Butler Bay Drive N. | 39 | 2 | $1,800,000 and $3,040,000, both on Lake Crescent |
| Unit 3: Lake Crescent Court | 20 | 4 | $900,000 and $915,000 off the lake; $1,507,000 and $1,525,000 on Lake Crescent |
| Unit 3: Lake Roberts Court | 22 | 4 | $970,000, $1,000,000 and $1,258,300 off the lake; $2,150,000 on Lake Roberts |
| Unit 3: Butler Bay Court | 37 | 1 | $870,000 |
| Unit 3 replat | 2 | 0 | No sales |
| All of Windermere Club | 147 | 13 | $870,000 to $3,040,000; median $1,400,000, about $384 per sq ft |
Pooled 24-month window, July 2024 to June 2026, qualified sales only. Sales from January 2025 on: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 Orange County tax roll, both sale fields, codes 01 and 02. Sales from July to December 2024: Orange County GIS parcel layer, latest qualified sale. One Butler Bay Court home recorded two qualified transfers in May 2025, at $831,200 and $870,000; we count it once, at the later $870,000. Checked October 29, 2026.
The two cul-de-sacs were the busiest. Lake Crescent Court and Lake Roberts Court together have 42 homes, and 8 of them sold in two years. Butler Bay Court, with 37 homes and no lake lots, recorded one sale.
The same-street pairs show what the lake is worth here. On Lake Crescent Court, two off-lake homes of about 2,800 sq ft sold for $900,000 and $915,000, and two lakefront homes of 3,274 and 3,756 sq ft sold for $1,507,000 and $1,525,000. On Lake Roberts Court, the one lakefront sale, $2,150,000, was a 4,678 sq ft home built in 2008 on about 1.6 acres; the three off-lake homes there sold for $970,000 to $1,258,300.
Lake lots and the rest
| Lakefront lots | Other lots | |
|---|---|---|
| Homes | 53 (41 Lake Crescent, 12 Lake Roberts) | 94 |
| Median home | 4,239 sq ft on 0.91 acre | 3,595 sq ft on 0.56 acre |
| Sales, Jul 2024 to Jun 2026 | 5 | 8 |
| Median sale | $1,800,000 | $985,000 |
| Sale prices | $1,507,000 to $3,040,000 | $870,000 to $1,650,000 |
| Median price per sq ft | About $460 | About $325 |
| Median 2026 just value | $1,328,920 | $749,330 |
Same sources and rules as above. Lake outlines: Orange County GIS hydrology layer, checked October 29, 2026.
At the median, a lakefront sale cost about $815,000 more than an off-lake one and about $135 more per square foot. The lake homes are also larger and sit on bigger lots, so part of that is the house. The highest sale, $3,040,000 in September 2025, was a 5,700 sq ft home on Lake Crescent, about $533 per square foot.
The two lakes are not alike for an owner's tax bill. The 22 homes on Lake Roberts Court, including its 12 lakefront homes, are in Orange County tax district 35. The other 125 Windermere Club homes, including all the Lake Crescent homes, are in district 75, which includes the Windermere Water and Navigation Control District's 0.2528 mill, roughly $25 a year for each $100,000 of taxable value. Lake Roberts, for its part, is on Orange County's list of lake-management taxing or benefit units, which are charged on the tax bill of the homes in the unit, so check a Lake Roberts Court home's tax notice for that line. Our article on lake taxes explains both. Neither lake is part of the Butler Chain, despite the Butler Bay name; our guide to lakefront homes beyond the Butler Chain covers lakes like Lake Crescent, and you should ask what boating and dock rules apply to a specific lake before you rely on them.
A busy year, then a quiet one
Ten of the 13 sales came in the first year, July 2024 to June 2025, at a median of $1,129,150. The second year recorded three: $1,400,000 in July 2025, $3,040,000 in September 2025 and $1,650,000 in May 2026. With three sales, the second year's higher median says more about which homes sold than about values.
One measure is steadier: the 13 homes sold for a median of 18% above their 2026 just value from the Property Appraiser. Most of the neighborhood is 30 to 40 years old: 54 homes were built in the 1980s, 75 in the 1990s, 16 in the 2000s and 2 since 2010. Ask for the roof's age and a four-point inspection early; our guide to buying an older home lists what to check.
Pricing a Windermere Club home
- Start with the street and the lake. In two years, off-lake homes sold from $870,000 to $1,650,000 and lakefront homes from $1,507,000 to $3,040,000. A median for the whole neighborhood mixes the two.
- Unit 2 is its own market. Its acre-plus lots and larger homes sold at about $384 to $402 per square foot off the lake, above every off-lake sale in Unit 3.
- Use more than 13 sales. Add recent sales of similar gated, large-lot homes nearby, and adjust for the lake, the lot and updates.
- Check the view behind the lot. Many homes back onto the former golf course, which has been closed since 2016.
For other gated neighborhoods and their prices, see our guide to gated communities in Windermere and our guide to luxury home prices by budget.
Frequently asked questions
What do homes sell for in Windermere Club?
Thirteen qualified sales from July 2024 to June 2026 ranged from $870,000 to $3,040,000, with a median of $1,400,000.
How much more do lakefront homes cost in Windermere Club?
Five lakefront sales had a median of $1,800,000, against $985,000 for eight off-lake sales. Per square foot, about $460 against $325.
Which lakes are in Windermere Club?
Lake Crescent, with 41 lakefront lots, and Lake Roberts, with 12, on Orange County's maps.
How big are the lots in Windermere Club?
Every lot is at least half an acre; the median is about 0.61 acre, and 40 homes have an acre or more, including all 27 in Butler Bay Unit 2.
How many homes are in Windermere Club?
147 homes on the 2026 tax roll, in Butler Bay Units 2 and 3 and a 1990 replat.
Is Butler Bay the same as Windermere Club?
Partly. Windermere Club is built on Butler Bay Units 2 and 3. Butler Bay Unit 1, inside the Town of Windermere, is a separate neighborhood.
Thinking of selling or buying in Windermere Club? We can pull every recorded sale on your street and the nearest lakefront sales, and walk the lot with you. Request a home value, contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256.
This article is general information from public records, not legal, tax or appraisal advice. Sale records can be incomplete; confirm lake frontage with a survey and the tax for a specific home with the Orange County Property Appraiser.
Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll via the Florida Geographic Information Office statewide cadastral service (homes, plats, living area, land area, year built, just value, tax districts, sales from January 2025; checked October 29, 2026); Orange County GIS, AGOL Open Data map service, Parcels layer (latest qualified sale for July to December 2024, pools), Subdivision layer (Butler Bay plats) and our lake match from its Hydrology layer (checked October 29, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser plat instruments and 2025 millage as reported in our Windermere Club golf course article (checked October 15, 2026); Water Atlas lake list for the Windermere Water and Navigation Control District as reported in our lake taxes article.
