Providence vs. Lake Sawyer South: Two Horizon West Neighborhoods Near Lake Sawyer (2026)
Quick answer: Providence and Lake Sawyer South are non-gated Horizon West neighborhoods with Windermere addresses, in the same tax district and with no CDD. Providence is older, with fewer homes: 216 houses built mostly 2003 to 2005, 23 of them on Little Lake Sawyer, with a $774,500 median. Lake Sawyer South has 414 houses and 140 townhomes from 2007 to 2012, with a $682,500 house median.
The two neighborhoods sit about a mile apart in the south end of Horizon West, and both carry a Sawyer name, but only one of them is on a lake. This comparison uses the 2026 Florida Department of Revenue tax roll, Orange County Property Appraiser records and tax notices, Orange County's plat and lake maps, and the Lake Sawyer South association's website. For more on each, see Providence homes and facts and the Lake Sawyer South community page.
Providence and Lake Sawyer South side by side
| Providence | Lake Sawyer South | |
|---|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | Unincorporated Orange County (Horizon West); not the Town of Windermere | Unincorporated Orange County (Horizon West); not the Town of Windermere |
| Gated | No | No |
| Homes | 216 single-family | 414 single-family, 140 townhomes |
| Mostly built | 2003 to 2005, by Morrison Homes | 2007 to 2012, by Pulte |
| Median single-family sale | $774,500 (8 sales) | $682,500 (16 sales) |
| Typical single-family home | 2,826 sq ft on 0.21 acre; $248 per sq ft | 2,608 sq ft on 0.16 acre; $254 per sq ft |
| Median townhome sale | No townhomes | $385,000 (6 sales); 1,680 sq ft |
| Lakefront home lots | 23, on Little Lake Sawyer | None |
| Property-tax rate, 2025 | 16.1366 mills | 16.1366 mills |
| Flat charges on 2026 tax notices | $714.24 | $677.58 |
| CDD | None in county records | None in county records |
| Association on the tax roll | Providence Neighborhood Association | Lake Sawyer South Community Association, managed by Leland Management |
| Zoned schools, 2026–27 | Windermere Elementary, Bridgewater Middle, Windermere High | Sunset Park Elementary, Horizon West Middle, Windermere High |
| Home lots touching a FEMA high-risk flood zone | 23 of 216 (11%) | 70 of 554 (13%) |
Homes, years, sizes and prices: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll; qualified sales from July 2025 to June 2026, counting both sales the roll keeps for each home. Builders: the first sale of 20 sampled homes in each neighborhood, Orange County Property Appraiser. Lakefront: home lots that touch the lake's outline on Orange County's map. Tax rates and charges: Property Appraiser 2025 and 2026 tax records for every home (checked October 21, 2026). Schools: our match of homes to Orange County Public Schools' 2026–27 zones. Flood: our match of home lots to FEMA's flood map.
Which one is on the lake
Providence is. On the county's map, 23 Providence home lots touch Little Lake Sawyer, a lake of about 61 acres, along Little Lake Sawyer Drive and Zori Lane. The Providence Neighborhood Association also owns two common tracts that reach the shore, one of 2.9 acres on Zori Lane and one of half an acre on Little Lake Sawyer Drive. We could not find the association's rules for those tracts, so ask what owners who are not on the water may use them for.
Lake Sawyer South is not on a lake, despite the name. None of its home lots touches a lake on the county's map; its nearest homes are about three-quarters of a mile from Little Lake Sawyer and a little farther from Lake Sawyer. What it has instead is a lot of protected land: its association owns tracts of 103 and 56 acres, and the association's website describes the conservation areas as restricted and off-limits, overseen by the St. Johns River Water Management District.
Neither neighborhood pays the Windermere navigation district tax that many homes on the Sawyer lakes pay. Little Lake Sawyer is one of the district's lakes, but Providence is outside its taxing boundary; our article on Windermere's lake taxes explains how that boundary works.
Prices and the homes you get
Providence's higher median comes mostly from the lake. Of its eight single-family sales in the year to June 2026, two were lakefront homes, at $2,150,000 for a 5,178 sq ft house on Little Lake Sawyer Drive in July 2025 and $1,699,900 on Zori Lane in March 2026. The other six sold for $560,000 to $900,000, with a median of $675,000. That is close to Lake Sawyer South, where 16 houses sold for $480,000 to $1,014,500 with a $682,500 median. Lakefront homes in Providence are much larger, typically 4,528 sq ft against 2,813 sq ft for the rest.
Away from the water, the trade-off is age against size. A typical Providence house is about 220 sq ft larger and sits on a bigger lot, 0.21 acre against 0.16, but most were built from 2003 to 2005, while Lake Sawyer South's were built from 2007 to 2012. Morrison Homes sold the new home in 18 of the 20 Providence homes we sampled, and Pulte sold all 20 we sampled in Lake Sawyer South. Private pools are much more common in Providence: county records show one at 102 of its 216 homes, against 97 of Lake Sawyer South's 554.
Only Lake Sawyer South has townhomes. Its 140 townhomes were built from 2007 to 2011, are typically 1,680 sq ft, and the six that sold in the year went for $365,000 to $393,000. Six sales is a small base, so compare recent sales on the same street.
Amenities and associations
The Lake Sawyer South association's website, checked in October 2026, lists a pool open from dawn to dusk, a playground open from 9 a.m. to dusk, sports courts open from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m., and a putting green, with the pool at 7420 Derexa Drive. The county's records show a 2009 association building there with 781 sq ft of living area. The association is managed by Leland Management, and its board meets monthly from January to October.
We could not find a website for the Providence Neighborhood Association. The county's records show an association pool site on Swansea Avenue, with a small building from 2009, plus the lake tracts above. Ask the seller or the manager for the current amenity list, rules and dues.
We could not find either association's dues published online. The HOA disclosure summary and the estoppel certificate will show what a specific home owes; our guide to HOA dues and CDDs explains both.
Property taxes
Every parcel in both neighborhoods is in the same tax district, so the same taxable value pays the same tax in either one. The 2025 rate was 16.1366 mills, about $8,068 a year on $500,000 of taxable value before flat charges, and the Property Appraiser's 2026 records show 16.0306 mills after the state school rate fell. Neither has a community development district: the county's parcel records show no CDD for any parcel in either.
The flat charges differ only in the street-light line. Every Providence notice for 2026 lists $430 for garbage collection, $78 for retention ponds and $206.24 for street lights, a total of $714.24. Every Lake Sawyer South notice has the same garbage and pond charges and $169.58 for street lights, a total of $677.58.
Schools, flood zones and utilities
For 2026–27, every Providence home we mapped is zoned for Windermere Elementary and Bridgewater Middle, and every Lake Sawyer South home for Sunset Park Elementary and Horizon West Middle. Both go to Windermere High. Zones change, so check any address in OCPS Find My School.
FEMA's high-risk flood zone reaches the edge of some lots in both. In Providence, 23 home lots touch it and the middle of the lot is inside it on 20, mostly near the lake. In Lake Sawyer South, 70 lots touch it but only 15 have the middle of the lot inside. A lender goes by the zone at the house, so check the flood map for the address; our flood zone guide shows how. Both neighborhoods are on Orange County Utilities water and sewer.
Which one fits what you want
- A home on a lake: Providence, where 23 lots front Little Lake Sawyer.
- A bigger lot or a home with a pool already in: Providence, on the county's records.
- A newer house for about the same price as an off-lake Providence home: Lake Sawyer South.
- A townhome under $400,000: Lake Sawyer South.
- An association with published amenity hours: Lake Sawyer South.
Neither choice changes your tax rate. To see these two next to the rest of the area, use our Horizon West neighborhood comparison.
Frequently asked questions
Is Lake Sawyer South on Lake Sawyer?
No. No Lake Sawyer South home lot touches a lake on Orange County's map; its nearest homes are about three-quarters of a mile from Little Lake Sawyer.
Are Providence and Lake Sawyer South in the Town of Windermere?
No. Both have Windermere, FL 34786 mailing addresses but are in Horizon West, in unincorporated Orange County.
Do Providence lakefront homes pay a lake tax?
No. Providence is outside the Windermere Water and Navigation Control District's taxing boundary, and its 2026 tax records show no lake levy.
Do Providence or Lake Sawyer South have CDD fees?
No. County parcel records show no CDD for either. Both have homeowners' association dues, which are billed separately from the tax bill.
Which one has more sales?
Lake Sawyer South, which has more than twice as many homes and recorded 22 sales in the year to June 2026, against eight in Providence.
Looking at the south end of Horizon West? We can show you homes in Providence and Lake Sawyer South in one trip and check the flood map and tax notice for each before you visit. Send us a note or call Infinity Realty Group, LLC at 407-234-2256.
This comparison is general information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Confirm dues, lake access, taxes, school zones and flood zones for a specific home before you buy.
Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll (homes, sizes, sales; checked October 21, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser, 2025 and 2026 tax records, 2026 non-ad valorem charges for every home, and sale histories for 20 sampled homes in each neighborhood (checked October 21, 2026); Orange County GIS, plats, parcels and lake outlines (checked October 21, 2026); Lake Sawyer South Community Association website (checked October 21, 2026); Orange County Water Atlas (lake size); Orange County Public Schools, 2026–27 school zones; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer.
