Independence and Signature Lakes Home Prices: What Sold and What Owners Pay (2026)
Quick answer: From July 2025 to June 2026, 42 off-lake houses in Independence and Signature Lakes sold for a median of $547,450, about 9% below the year before. Five Lake Hancock houses sold for a median of $2,775,000, about five times as much. The 23 townhome sales had a $405,000 median, a little above the year before. There is no CDD.
Independence is the community's name and its association's; Signature Lakes is the name on its plats, deeds and tax bills. It sits in Horizon West, unincorporated Orange County, with Winter Garden 34787 addresses. Our page on homes in Independence and Signature Lakes has the overview, and our article on whether Independence and Signature Lakes are one community explains the two names and the 11 plats. Here we look only at money: what sold on the Florida Department of Revenue's 2026 tax roll, how the lake lots, the sections and the townhomes priced, and what an owner pays.
What sold: 47 houses and 23 townhomes
Signature Lakes legal descriptions cover 1,838 homes on the 2026 roll, 1,291 single-family houses and 547 townhomes, mostly built from 2006 to 2015. None of the year's sales was a new home.
| Sale price | Sales | Living area | Price per sq ft | Lot | Year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Houses $400,000 to $499,999 | 15 | 1,644 to 2,203 sq ft | $217 to $284 | 0.10 to 0.22 acre | 2005 to 2017 |
| Houses $500,000 to $599,999 | 16 | 1,863 to 3,436 sq ft | $153 to $290 | 0.09 to 0.26 acre | 2005 to 2016 |
| Houses $600,000 to $699,999 | 6 | 2,233 to 3,152 sq ft | $206 to $281 | 0.15 to 0.25 acre | 2006 to 2017 |
| Houses $700,000 to $999,999 | 5 | 2,347 to 4,502 sq ft | $215 to $307 | 0.23 to 0.27 acre | 2006 to 2017 |
| Houses on Lake Hancock | 5, median $2,775,000 | 5,083 to 6,601 sq ft | $438 to $600 | 1.39 to 2.19 acres | 2006 to 2022 |
| All 42 off-lake houses | Median $547,450 | Median 2,392 sq ft | Median $239 | Most under a quarter acre | 2005 to 2017 |
| All 23 townhomes | Median $405,000 | Median 1,624 sq ft | Median $242 | 0.05 to 0.19 acre | 2005 to 2017 |
Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll, homes whose legal description begins "Signature Lakes," qualified sales (codes 01 and 02) from both sale slots, July 2025 to June 2026. Lake lots from Orange County's lake map. Checked October 28, 2026.
Counting all 47 houses together gives a $565,000 median, the figure on our community page. For almost every buyer the off-lake figure is the useful one: the off-lake houses that sold had 1,644 to 4,502 sq ft, most on less than a quarter acre, and the highest off-lake sale in the year was $970,000. No house sold between $970,000 and $2,385,000. The pool is a visible dividing line: 286 of the 1,291 houses have one on the county record, and the 11 pool houses that sold had a median of $800,000, against $524,950 for the rest, partly because they were larger.
Lake Hancock and Lake Speer
Of the 1,291 house lots, 109 reach the water on the county's maps: 84 on Lake Hancock and 25 on Lake Speer. These are estate lots, with a median of about 1.56 acres against about 0.17 acre for the community. Every townhome sits back from both lakes.
| Section | Lake | Lake lots | Sales, Jul 2024 to Jun 2025 | Sales, Jul 2025 to Jun 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Parcel 1C | Hancock | 29 | 2: $2,050,000 and $2,700,000 | 2: $2,385,000 and $3,050,000 |
| Parcel 1D | Hancock | 21 | 2: $1,710,000 and $2,159,000 (a new home) | None |
| Phase 2 | Hancock | 34 | 2: $1,885,000 and $2,640,000 | 3: $2,675,000, $2,775,000 and $3,600,000 |
| Phases 3B | Speer | 25 | 2: $1,100,000 and $1,338,000 | None |
Lake lot: a house parcel touching the lake outline in Orange County's hydrology layer (Orange County GIS, checked October 28, 2026). Sales: 2026 roll sale slots and the county's last-qualified-sale record.
Two points come out of a small set of sales. Lake Hancock prices rose: the six Hancock sales a year earlier ran from $1.71 million to $2.7 million, and this year's five from $2.385 million to $3.6 million, the two highest on houses built in 2019 and 2022. And Lake Speer lots have sold for far less than Hancock lots: the only two Speer sales in two years were $1.1 million and $1.338 million. With so few sales, price a lake home from the two or three closest lake sales on the same lake, not from a median. Our guide to lakefront homes beyond the Butler Chain covers Lake Hancock's other communities.
Prices by section
Off the lake, the sections are closer in price than their ages suggest.
| Section (plat) | Houses | Mostly built | Typical house and lot | Off-lake house sales | Townhome sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Parcel 1A | 86, and 110 townhomes | 2005 to 2010 | 2,233 sq ft, 0.14 acre | 6, median $477,500 | 7, median $380,000 |
| Parcel 1B | 118, and 56 townhomes | 2005 to 2006 | 2,373 sq ft, 0.16 acre | 3, median $539,900 | 2 |
| Parcel 1C | 272, and 16 townhomes | 2006 to 2011 | 2,797 sq ft, 0.17 acre | 6, median $569,500 | 1 |
| Parcel 1D | 90, and 133 townhomes | 2007 to 2014 | 3,362 sq ft, 0.22 acre | 3, median $525,000 | 6, median $348,750 |
| Phase 2 | 385, and 125 townhomes | 2011 to 2014 | 2,443 sq ft, 0.16 acre | 12, median $572,500 | 3, median $410,000 |
| Phase 2A | 41 | 2014 to 2016 | 2,093 sq ft, 0.14 acre | 2 | None (no townhomes) |
| Phases 3B | 299, and 107 townhomes in 3B-6 | 2014 to 2017 | 2,860 sq ft, 0.18 acre | 10, median $542,500 | 4, median $409,000 |
Florida Department of Revenue 2026 tax roll, grouped by the plat named in each legal description; Phases 3B-1 to 3B-7 combined. "Mostly built" is the 10th to 90th percentile. Medians only for three or more sales. Checked October 28, 2026.
Parcel 1A, the first section built, had the lowest off-lake median, at $477,500 for houses of about 2,200 sq ft. Phase 2 and Parcel 1C, mid-2000s to mid-2010s houses of 2,400 to 2,800 sq ft, sold for about $570,000. Townhomes split by section too. Parcel 1D's townhomes, typically 1,466 sq ft on about 0.05 acre, sold for a median of $348,750, the lowest in the community; one sold for $197,500, about 64% of the county's just value, so treat it with care. Phase 2 and 3B-6 townhomes, about 1,750 to 1,790 sq ft, sold for about $410,000. The association says each of its four townhome groups has its own association and board, so the townhome's section can also change the dues.
A year earlier: houses down, townhomes up
| Jul 2024 to Jun 2025 | Jul 2025 to Jun 2026 | |
|---|---|---|
| Off-lake houses | 62, median $600,000, $247 per sq ft | 42, median $547,450, $239 per sq ft |
| Off-lake houses under 2,500 sq ft | 29, median $535,000, $262 per sq ft | 22, median $476,000, $260 per sq ft |
| Off-lake houses 2,500 sq ft and up | 33, median $675,000, $227 per sq ft | 20, median $580,000, $212 per sq ft |
| Townhomes | 30, median $391,250 | 23, median $405,000 |
Earlier year: Orange County GIS parcel layer, last qualified sale, plus 2026-roll sale slots dated July 2024 to June 2025; close to complete, not exact. Small samples.
Part of the 9% drop in the off-lake median comes from smaller houses making up more of the sales. Per square foot, smaller houses held their price, while houses of 2,500 sq ft and more sold for about 6% less per foot than a year earlier. Townhomes rose about 3.5%, with the price per square foot about the same. Fewer sales, from 62 to 42 off-lake houses, also points to a slower year.
What owners pay
Tax district 35, unincorporated Orange County, covers all 1,838 homes; with no exemptions its 2026 rate totals 16.0306 mills. No home here has a community development district in the county's parcel data.
| Estimated 2026 property tax | Houses | Townhomes |
|---|---|---|
| Current owners with homestead, median | $5,338 (836 houses) | $3,036 (311 homes) |
| Current owners without homestead, median | $8,088 (455 houses) | $5,428 (236 homes) |
| A buyer at the off-lake median, with homestead | About $8,100 at $547,450 | About $5,800 at $405,000 |
| The same buyer, without homestead | About $8,800 | About $6,500 |
| A buyer at the Lake Hancock median, with homestead | About $43,800 at $2,775,000 | Not applicable |
Current owners: 2026 taxable values on the Florida Department of Revenue roll times the certified 2026 rates (school 6.343 mills; matches Orange County Property Appraiser certified 2026 taxes on sampled homes); homestead where the roll shows an exemption of $25,000 or more. Checked October 28, 2026. Buyer lines are an illustration only, assuming the assessed value equals the price: school 6.343 mills on value less $25,000 and other taxes 9.6876 mills on value less $51,411 with homestead; 16.0306 mills on the full value without. The November 2026 bill is final.
Homes sold for a median 13% (houses) and 18% (townhomes) above their 2026 just value, and homesteaded houses are assessed at about two-thirds of it, so a buyer's bill usually lands well above the seller's. The reset is covered in our article on how Orange County property tax changes after you buy.
Add the county's flat charges: in our October 2026 check of 15 homes across the plats, each carried $709.62 for garbage, retention ponds and street lights. Association dues come on top. We did not find dues published online for Independence Community Association, which owns 149 common parcels on the roll, or for the townhome associations, so ask for the HOA disclosure summary for each association a home belongs to, and confirm the amounts on the estoppel certificate.
What to do with these numbers
- Buying off the lake: compare within the section and by size; houses over 2,500 sq ft softened most in the year.
- Buying a townhome: Parcel 1D is the lowest-priced section, and Phase 2 and 3B-6 the highest; check which townhome association the home belongs to before you compare dues.
- Buying on a lake: Lake Hancock and Lake Speer are different markets. Use sales on the same lake.
- Selling: the year-earlier prices are a ceiling more than a floor for larger off-lake houses right now.
To compare these numbers with Horizon West's other communities, see our Horizon West communities guide.
Frequently asked questions
What is the median home price in Independence and Signature Lakes?
$565,000 across all 47 house sales from July 2025 to June 2026, or $547,450 for the 42 off the lakes. Townhomes sold for a median of $405,000.
What do Lake Hancock homes in Independence sell for?
Five sold in the year for $2,385,000 to $3,600,000, a median of $2,775,000, on lots of 1.39 to 2.19 acres.
Are home prices falling in Independence?
For larger off-lake houses, yes: about 6% less per square foot than a year earlier. Smaller houses held their price per square foot, and townhomes rose slightly.
Does Independence have a CDD?
No. The county's parcel records show no CDD. Owners pay county flat charges of about $710 and association dues.
How much are property taxes in Independence and Signature Lakes?
The median 2026 tax for a homesteaded house is about $5,300. Buy at the $547,450 off-lake median, claim homestead, and expect about $8,100 plus the county's flat charges.
Considering a home in Independence? We can pull recorded sales in the same section, or on the same lake, and estimate the first-year tax before you make an offer. Contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256.
This article is general information from public records, not legal, tax or appraisal advice. Values, rates and exemptions change; confirm the tax for a specific home with the Orange County Property Appraiser and Tax Collector, and every association charge in writing.
Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll via the Florida Geographic Information Office statewide cadastral service (homes, sales, living area, land area, year built, just, assessed and taxable value, common-area owner; checked October 28, 2026); Orange County GIS, AGOL Open Data map service, Parcels layer (CDD field, pool, last qualified sale) and Hydrology layer (Lake Hancock, Lake Speer outlines) (checked October 28, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser 2026 non-ad valorem charges for 15 sample homes and Independence Community website, as reported in our Independence vs. Signature Lakes article (checked October 15, 2026); Florida Statutes section 193.155 (checked October 2026).
