What Is My Home Worth? Windermere, Winter Garden and Dr. Phillips (2026)

Quick answer: A home is usually worth close to what similar homes in the same community sold for recently. For a first estimate, multiply your home's heated square feet by your community's median price per square foot in the table below, then adjust for the things that set your home apart, such as lake frontage, lot size, updates and condition. Across the 50 communities we track, median prices ran from $199 per sq ft in Johns Lake Pointe to $745 in Isleworth (single-family sales, July 2025 to June 2026). For a number you can price or plan with, ask us for a no-obligation comparative market analysis based on the latest sales in your own subdivision.

A quick estimate in two steps

  1. Find your community in the table and note its median price per square foot.
  2. Multiply it by your home's heated living area (it is on your tax bill and on the Orange County Property Appraiser's record).

Example: a 3,500 sq ft home in Keene's Pointe at the community's median of $428 per sq ft gives about $1,500,000. Keene's Pointe's single-family homes sold from $775,000 to $13,200,000 in the same period, so where a home falls in that range depends on its lot, view and condition.

Home prices and price per square foot by community

Single-family homes only, from qualified sales recorded in the Florida Department of Revenue's 2026 county tax roll. "(few)" means fewer than 5 sales, so treat that median with care. For townhomes, see townhome and condo prices.

CommunityAreaMedian sale priceMedian price per sq ftTypical home size, sq ftRange of salesSales
CasabellaWindermere$3,097,500$4146,757$2,100,000 to $3,275,0006
Chaine Du LacWindermere$2,400,000$4365,961$1,975,000 to $3,150,0003 (few)
GlenmuirWindermere$865,000$2993,068$515,000 to $1,010,00010
IsleworthWindermere$4,330,000$7456,192$2,360,000 to $11,500,00019
Keene's PointeWindermere$1,525,000$4283,885$775,000 to $13,200,00062
Kelso on Lake ButlerWindermere$1,865,000$6424,105$1,535,000 to $5,150,0004 (few)
Lake Burden SouthWindermere$1,350,000$2773,461$970,000 to $1,710,0005
The Reserve at Lake Butler SoundWindermere$2,100,000$4165,585$1,335,000 to $6,800,00011
Tildens GroveWindermere$1,170,000$3314,398$1,050,000 to $1,750,0003 (few)
Waterford PointeWindermere$2,075,000$4494,197$1,400,000 to $2,650,0004 (few)
WaterstoneWindermere$1,517,500$4234,694$1,300,000 to $4,030,0008
Westover ClubWindermere$831,250$2673,390$765,000 to $1,100,0006
Windermere DownsWindermere$825,000$2982,978$670,000 to $2,404,00011
Lake Sawyer SouthWindermere (Horizon West)$682,500$2542,608$480,000 to $1,014,50016
Lakes of WindermereWindermere (Horizon West)$567,500$2402,460$500,000 to $1,560,00028
ProvidenceWindermere (Horizon West)$774,500$2482,826$560,000 to $2,150,0008
SummerportWindermere (Horizon West)$595,000$2512,618$479,000 to $979,00024
VineyardsWindermere (Horizon West)$637,500$2142,724$585,000 to $645,0004 (few)
Wickham ParkWindermere (Horizon West)$495,000$2861,696$426,000 to $525,0006
Windermere IsleWindermere (Horizon West)$1,140,000$2813,336$680,000 to $1,200,0005
Windermere TrailsWindermere (Horizon West)$716,250$2363,038$465,000 to $1,045,00024
Alexander RidgeWinter Garden$539,250$2322,562$499,000 to $900,0006
Bronson's LandingWinter Garden$825,000$2283,766$645,000 to $1,039,0005
Carriage Pointe & Reserve at Carriage PointeWinter Garden$772,500$2072,881$565,000 to $935,00013
Hickory HammockWinter Garden$1,165,000$3083,531$590,000 to $2,700,00023
Johns Lake PointeWinter Garden$740,000$1993,164$540,000 to $1,350,00013
Oakland ParkWinter Garden$980,000$3582,681$760,000 to $1,695,00035
Stoneybrook WestWinter Garden$622,500$2442,505$413,300 to $839,00046
Sunset LakesWinter Garden$992,500$3402,820$750,000 to $1,250,0004 (few)
Windermere CrossingWinter Garden$755,000$2063,002$680,000 to $800,0003 (few)
Wintermere HarborWinter Garden$800,000$2862,876$765,000 to $905,0003 (few)
Wintermere PointeWinter Garden$580,000$2002,901$469,000 to $880,0009
Avalon CoveWinter Garden (Horizon West)$2,254,000$4344,436$2,050,000 to $2,340,0003 (few)
Del Webb OasisWinter Garden (Horizon West)$575,000$2882,028$380,000 to $1,291,50041
HawksmoorWinter Garden (Horizon West)$630,000$2552,470$485,000 to $930,0007
Highlands at Summerlake GrovesWinter Garden (Horizon West)$739,000$2772,613$479,000 to $1,400,10011
Lakeview PointeWinter Garden (Horizon West)$538,750$2512,368$480,000 to $729,00014
Latham ParkWinter Garden (Horizon West)$845,000$2552,824$515,000 to $1,700,0009
Orchard HillsWinter Garden (Horizon West)$595,000$2432,814$515,000 to $825,00017
Orchard ParkWinter Garden (Horizon West)$595,000$2362,560$490,000 to $870,00011
Storey GroveWinter Garden (Horizon West)$527,500$2282,486$447,600 to $770,00020
SummerlakeWinter Garden (Horizon West)$597,500$2392,668$470,000 to $2,461,00056
The Enclave at HamlinWinter Garden (Horizon West)$635,000$2582,459$592,900 to $823,0003 (few)
WaterleighWinter Garden (Horizon West)$688,100$2612,477$434,900 to $2,000,000126
WatermarkWinter Garden (Horizon West)$702,500$2582,204$450,000 to $1,250,00034
Cypress PointDr. Phillips$1,970,000$4115,362$1,300,000 to $9,500,0007
Phillips LandingDr. Phillips$1,196,000$3483,667$875,000 to $1,600,0009
Sand Lake PointDr. Phillips$675,000$2982,403$565,000 to $885,00012
South BayDr. Phillips$1,075,000$3283,488$850,000 to $1,457,00011
Johns LandingOakland$600,000$2123,190$474,000 to $2,275,00015

Source: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 county tax roll (Orange County), qualified single-family sales July 2025 to June 2026; price per sq ft uses heated living area. A median is the middle sale: half sold for more and half for less. Communities with fewer than 3 sales are not shown. Full rankings are in home prices by neighborhood.

What moves a home above or below the median

  • Water and views: lakefront, especially on the Butler Chain of Lakes, and golf-course lots usually sell above the community median.
  • Lot size and position: a larger, private or corner lot compared with the homes around it.
  • Updates and condition: kitchens, baths, flooring and a newer roof and air conditioning system matter to buyers, and to insurers.
  • Size: price per square foot usually falls as homes get larger, so very large homes often sell below the median per square foot.
  • Timing: the table covers sales up to June 2026; the market can move after that.

Your tax value is not your market value

The Orange County Property Appraiser's "just value" is set as of January 1 each year for property taxes. It is not an appraisal of what a buyer would pay today, and homesteaded homes also have a capped assessed value that can be far below market value. Online estimates use the same public records and can miss a remodel, a view or a lake. See how Orange County property taxes work.

How we prepare a comparative market analysis

We start with sales in your own subdivision from the last 90 days, within about 15% of your home's size. If there are not enough, we widen the time or the area step by step and say so. Then we compare lots, views, updates and condition the way a buyer would, and give you a price range with the sales behind it. You are not committing to list. See how we sell homes.

Frequently asked questions

How much is my home worth in Windermere?

Start with your community's median price per square foot in the table above and multiply by your home's heated square feet. Inside the Town of Windermere, the median single-family home sold for $1,289,000 from July 2025 to June 2026.

How much is my home worth in Winter Garden?

Inside the City of Winter Garden, the median single-family sale was $665,000 from July 2025 to June 2026; most Horizon West communities sold between about $530,000 and $850,000. Use the table for your community.

Is the Property Appraiser's just value what my home will sell for?

No. Just value is set as of January 1 for taxes and often differs from the price a buyer pays. Recent sales of similar homes are the better guide.

How do I get a no-obligation home valuation?

Fill in the form below or call Infinity Realty Group, LLC at 407-234-2256. We prepare a comparative market analysis from the latest sales in your subdivision.

Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 county tax roll (Orange County); Orange County Property Appraiser, just value and Save Our Homes; Infinity Realty Group, comparative market analysis method.

Request a No-Obligation Home Value Analysis

Tell us about your home. We reply with a price range and the recent sales behind it.