Highlands at Summerlake Groves Home Prices: What Sold and What Owners Pay (2026)
Quick answer: Fourteen Highlands at Summerlake Groves houses back onto Huckleberry Lake, and the two that sold from July 2025 to June 2026 brought $1,350,000 and $1,400,100, about $490 per square foot. The other nine houses sold for a $725,000 median, about $273 per square foot, the same rate as a year earlier. Five townhomes sold for a $430,000 median.
Highlands at Summerlake Groves is a non-gated Horizon West neighborhood of houses and townhomes with Winter Garden 34787 addresses in unincorporated Orange County. For the overview, see our Highlands at Summerlake Groves community page. Whether it belongs to Summerlake, and which associations own its common land, is settled in our article Is Highlands at Summerlake Groves part of Summerlake?, so this post does not repeat it. Here we look only at money: every qualified sale in the last 12 months on record, the lake lots that pull the median up, how the five recorded phases differ, and what owners pay in property tax. The figures come from the Florida Department of Revenue's 2026 tax roll and Orange County's parcel, plat and lake maps.
What sold: 11 houses and 5 townhomes
The 2026 tax roll counts 355 homes in the Highlands plats: 303 single-family houses and 52 townhomes. From July 2025 to June 2026, 16 of them sold in qualified (arm's-length) sales, all resales.
| Sale price | Sales | Living area | Price per sq ft | Lot | Year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Townhomes | 5 | 1,868 to 2,256 sq ft | $191 to $236 | 0.06 to 0.09 acre | 2015 to 2017 |
| Houses under $600,000 | 3 | 1,654 to 2,440 sq ft | $242 to $290 | 0.12 to 0.13 acre | 2017 |
| Houses $600,000 to $899,999 | 5 | 2,571 to 3,635 sq ft | $238 to $282 | 0.15 to 0.20 acre | 2017 to 2021 |
| Houses $1 million and up | 3 | 2,781 to 4,018 sq ft | $309 to $502 | 0.19 to 0.36 acre | 2021 |
| All 11 houses | Median $739,000 | Median 2,781 sq ft | Median $277 | Median 0.18 acre | Median 2020 |
| All 5 townhomes | Median $430,000 ($390,000 to $465,000) | Median 2,196 sq ft | Median $206 | Median 0.06 acre | Median 2017 |
Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll, homes in the Highlands at Summerlake Groves plats, qualified sales (codes 01 and 02) from both sale slots, July 2025 to June 2026. Living area and lot are as recorded on the roll. Checked October 28, 2026.
The cheapest house, 1,654 sq ft from 2017, sold for $479,000; the dearest, a 2021 lake home, for $1,400,100. One off-lake sale stands out: a 4,018 sq ft house built in 2021 on a 0.19-acre lot sold for $1,240,000 in March 2026, about $309 per square foot and 58% above its 2026 just value. It is the only off-lake house above $900,000 in the year, so do not read it as the going rate for a large Highlands home.
The 14 Huckleberry Lake lots
On Orange County's parcel and lake maps, 14 Highlands house lots reach Huckleberry Lake, which covers about 93 acres: 11 on Sunstar Way in Phase 3C and 3 on Sweet Lemon Way in Phase 3B. No other Highlands lot touches a named lake, and no townhome does. These homes are a different product from the rest of the neighborhood.
| Huckleberry Lake lots | Other house lots | |
|---|---|---|
| Houses | 14 | 289 |
| Built | 2020 to 2021 | 2015 to 2021, most by 2018 |
| Living area, median | 3,601 sq ft (2,781 to 4,317) | 2,613 sq ft (1,654 to 4,188) |
| Lot on the 2026 roll | 0.31 to 0.55 acre | 0.12 to 0.34 acre; median 0.15 |
| 2026 just value, median | $1,195,935 | $593,470 |
| Qualified sales, Jul 2025 to Jun 2026 | 2: $1,350,000 and $1,400,100 | 9: $479,000 to $1,240,000; median $725,000 |
| Price per sq ft | About $485 and $502 | Median about $273 |
Lake lots: the lot touches a named lake in Orange County's hydrology map (Huckleberry Lake, 93.5 acres on the map), using the county's current parcel outlines (Orange County GIS, checked October 28, 2026). Sales and values: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 tax roll.
The two lake sales were 2,781 and 2,790 sq ft, smaller than the typical lake house, yet they sold for nearly twice the off-lake median. One more Sunstar Way lake home sold for $1,339,900 in May 2025, and after our window, the Orange Observer reported a 3,607 sq ft Sunstar Way home built in 2021 selling for $1,900,000 in July 2026. That address is one of the 14 lake lots. A Highlands lake home is priced against those few sales, not against the neighborhood median.
The 2026 replats
The lake lots changed shape in 2026. The Summerlake Groves Community Association recorded a replat of part of Phase 3B on February 27, 2026 (Plat Book 120, Page 56), covering the three Sweet Lemon Way lake lots, and a replat of part of Phase 3C on September 4, 2026 (Plat Book 122, Page 1), covering the 11 Sunstar Way lake lots. On the 2026 tax roll, which is set as of January 1, these lots are 0.31 to 0.55 acre. On the county's current parcel map they are 1.18 to 3.03 acres and run to the water. We could not find a public source that explains what the added land is, whether it carries conservation or drainage restrictions, or what dock rights it gives. If you are buying one of these homes, read the replat, the deed and the association's documents, and have the title company and a survey confirm the boundary. The 2027 values of the enlarged parcels may differ from the 2026 figures here.
Off the lake: flat per square foot, lower median
For July 2024 to June 2025 we combined the county's record of each home's last qualified sale with the earlier sale slot on the 2026 roll. That misses a home only if it sold in the second half of 2024 and again within the following year, so treat the earlier figures as close to complete.
| Jul 2024 to Jun 2025 | Jul 2025 to Jun 2026 | |
|---|---|---|
| Off-lake house sales | 8, median $794,500 | 9, median $725,000 |
| Off-lake median price per sq ft | About $272 | About $273 |
| Off-lake median living area | About 2,890 sq ft | 2,613 sq ft |
| Lake house sales | 1, $1,339,900 | 2, $1,350,000 and $1,400,100 |
| Townhome sales | 4, median $439,950 (about $215 per sq ft) | 5, median $430,000 (about $206 per sq ft) |
Earlier year: Orange County GIS parcel layer, last qualified sale, plus 2026-roll sale slots dated July 2024 to June 2025. All sales in both years were resales.
The off-lake median fell about 9%, but the houses that sold were smaller. Measured per square foot, off-lake prices held at about $272 to $273 across the two years. On eight and nine sales, price per square foot is the steadier guide.
Five phases, built in two waves
Highlands was recorded in five phases. Orange County's plat records name K. Hovnanian at the Highlands at Summerlake Grove LLC as developer of Phases 1, 3A, 3B and 3C, and CW PH2 Summer LLC as developer of Phase 2. The earlier phases are smaller houses on smaller lots; the last two, finished from 2019 to 2021, are about 700 to 1,000 sq ft larger and hold every lake lot.
| Phase (plat recorded) | Houses | Living area, median | Lot, median | Built | 2026 just value, median | House sales, Jul 2025 to Jun 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phase 1 (July 2015) | 99, plus all 52 townhomes | 2,613 sq ft | 0.15 acre | 2015 to 2019 | $579,310 | 3 ($520,000 to $670,000) |
| Phase 2 (January 2017) | 109 | 2,600 sq ft | 0.14 acre | 2017 to 2020 | $563,460 | 2 ($479,000 and $865,000) |
| Phase 3A (April 2017) | 14 | 2,119 sq ft | 0.12 acre | 2018 | $467,830 | None |
| Phase 3B (August 2019) | 46, 3 on the lake | 3,304 sq ft | 0.20 acre | 2019 to 2021 | $703,485 | 1 ($739,000) |
| Phase 3C (March 2020) | 35, 11 on the lake | 3,607 sq ft | 0.19 acre | 2020 to 2021 | $723,090 | 5 ($725,000 to $1,400,100) |
Phases: Orange County GIS subdivision layer (plat names, developers and recording dates), matched to parcels by subdivision number. Homes, sizes, years and values: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 tax roll. Checked October 28, 2026.
Phases 1 and 2, built mostly from 2016 to 2018 on lots of about 0.15 acre, are the core of the neighborhood: 208 of the 303 houses. Phase 3B and 3C houses, built later and larger, carry just values about $120,000 to $160,000 higher. Across all 303 houses, 37 were finished in 2016, 66 in 2017, 109 in 2018, 15 in 2019, 43 in 2020 and 32 in 2021; just 1 dates from 2015.
Townhomes: all in Phase 1
All 52 townhomes are in Phase 1, built from 2015 to 2017, and they vary little: every one has 1,868 to 2,256 sq ft on 0.06 to 0.10 acre, 48 have three bedrooms, and none has a pool on the county record. Their median 2026 just value is $367,190. The five sales ran from $390,000 to $465,000, a median about 9% above just value, while the houses sold a median 23% above theirs. About half the townhomes, 27 of 52, carry a homestead exemption; the other 25 are taxed at the full rate, which matters if you compare a seller's bill with your own (see the tax table below). For how Horizon West townhomes compare more widely, see our townhomes and condos guide.
The homes behind the prices
| Measure | Houses (303) | Townhomes (52) |
|---|---|---|
| Living area, median | 2,613 sq ft (most 2,115 to 3,635) | 1,868 sq ft (1,868 to 2,256) |
| Lot, median | 0.15 acre (most 0.12 to 0.23) | 0.06 acre |
| Year built, median | 2018 | 2017 |
| Bedrooms (off-lake houses) | 3: 100; 4: 97; 5: 84; 6: 8 | 3: 48; 4: 4 |
| Pool (off-lake houses) | 86 of 289 | None |
| 2026 just value, median | $600,610 (most $471,910 to $779,840) | $367,190 |
Florida Department of Revenue 2026 tax roll (size, lot, year, just value; "most" is the 10th to 90th percentile) and Orange County GIS parcel layer (bedrooms, pool; the 14 replatted lake lots are not yet complete on that layer), checked October 28, 2026.
Property taxes
All 355 Highlands homes fall in tax district 35, the unincorporated Orange County rate: 16.0306 mills on the county's 2026 estimates when a home has no exemptions. None carries a community development district (CDD) on the county's parcel records.
| Estimated 2026 property tax | Off-lake houses | Townhomes |
|---|---|---|
| Current owners, median | $7,227 | $5,485 |
| With a homestead exemption | $6,605 (219 homes) | $4,095 (27 homes) |
| Without a homestead exemption | $9,171 (65 homes) | $6,281 (25 homes) |
| A buyer at the median price, with homestead | About $10,970 at $725,000 | About $6,240 at $430,000 |
| A buyer at the median price, without homestead | About $11,620 | About $6,890 |
Current owners: 2026 taxable values on the Florida Department of Revenue 2026 tax roll at the certified 2026 rate for the home's tax district, which matched the Property Appraiser's certified 2026 taxes to the cent on three sampled homes, checked October 28, 2026. Buyer lines are an illustration only, assuming the assessed value equals the price: school 6.343 mills on value less $25,000 and other taxes 9.6876 mills on value less $51,411 with homestead; 16.0306 mills on the full value without. The November 2026 bill is final.
A lake home is in a different bracket. The three replatted Sweet Lemon Way lake homes carry certified 2026 taxes of about $19,860 to $20,830, and a buyer at about $1.375 million, the midpoint of this year's two lake sales, should plan on roughly $21,400 to $22,000. A sample 2026 Highlands tax notice also carried $674.85 of flat charges, including $430 for garbage and $166.85 for street lights. The tax resets after a sale, so the seller's bill is not yours; our article on why the bill goes up after you buy explains how.
We found no published dues for the Highlands or Summerlake Groves associations. Get the amounts, and the name of every association the home belongs to, from the seller's HOA disclosure summary and the estoppel certificate; our guide to the HOA documents to read before you buy covers both.
What to do with these numbers
- Buying off the lake: start at about $270 per square foot for a house, then adjust for phase, lot and pool. A Phase 1 or 2 house and a Phase 3B or 3C house of the same size are not the same comparison.
- Buying on Huckleberry Lake: three recorded sales from May 2025 to June 2026 ran $1.34 million to $1.4 million, and a July 2026 sale reached $1.9 million. Read the 2026 replat for the lot before you rely on any acreage.
- Buying a townhome: the 52 units are nearly identical, so the last five sales, $390,000 to $465,000, are a tight guide.
- Selling: houses sold a median 23% above their 2026 just value and townhomes about 9% above, so the Property Appraiser's figure has run well below what buyers paid.
To see Highlands next to the rest of the area, our Horizon West communities guide sets the medians side by side, and our breakdown of what Summerlake homes sold for gives the comparison buyers most often ask about.
Frequently asked questions
What is the median home price in Highlands at Summerlake Groves?
For houses, $739,000 across 11 qualified sales from July 2025 to June 2026; for townhomes, $430,000 across 5. Without the two Huckleberry Lake sales, the house median was $725,000.
Is Highlands at Summerlake Groves on a lake?
Fourteen of its 303 house lots reach Huckleberry Lake, about 93 acres on the county's map: 11 on Sunstar Way and 3 on Sweet Lemon Way. The rest do not touch a named lake.
What do lakefront homes in Highlands at Summerlake Groves sell for?
Two sold from July 2025 to June 2026, for $1,350,000 and $1,400,100, about $490 per square foot. Another sold for $1,339,900 in May 2025.
How much are property taxes in Highlands at Summerlake Groves?
Owners' 2026 taxes run a median of about $7,200 for an off-lake house and $5,500 for a townhome. A buyer at $725,000 should plan for about $11,000 to $11,600 plus about $675 of flat charges.
Does Highlands at Summerlake Groves have a CDD?
No. None of the 355 Highlands homes shows a CDD in Orange County's parcel records.
Buying or selling in Highlands at Summerlake Groves? We can pull the recorded sales closest to a specific home, by phase or on the lake, and estimate the first-year tax. Contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256.
This article is general information from public records, not legal, tax, survey or appraisal advice. Values, rates, dues and lot lines change; confirm the tax with the Orange County Property Appraiser and Tax Collector, the association charges on the disclosure summary and estoppel certificate, and any lake lot's boundary and rights with the title company and a survey.
Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll via the Florida Geographic Information Office statewide cadastral service (homes, sales, living area, land area, year built, just value, 2026 taxable values; checked October 28, 2026); Orange County GIS, AGOL Open Data map service, Parcels layer (tax code, CDD field, pool, bedrooms, current parcel outlines, last qualified sale), Subdivision layer (plats, developers, recording dates, including the 2026 replats of Phases 3B and 3C) and Hydrology layer (Huckleberry Lake outline) (checked October 28, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser, 2026 Notice of Proposed Property Taxes for a sample Highlands parcel, as reported in our Highlands and Summerlake article (checked October 18, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser certified 2026 taxes for 6 sampled homes (checked October 28, 2026); Orange Observer, Horizon West home sales, July 14, 2026 (checked October 28, 2026); Florida Statutes sections 193.155 and 720.401 (checked October 2026).
