Windermere vs Winter Garden, FL: Taxes, Home Prices and Town Limits Compared (2026)
Quick answer: "Windermere" means two places. The Town of Windermere is a small, older lakeside town of 1,195 single-family homes, with a median sale price of $1,289,000. Around it, the much larger Windermere area outside the town limits (ZIP 34786, unincorporated Orange County) has about 13,570 homes, including Isleworth, Keene's Pointe and Lake Butler Sound, with a median single-family price of $934,750. Winter Garden is a growing city of 14,874 homes with a median of $665,000. In 2025 the total property-tax rate was 15.4839 mills in the Town of Windermere, 16.1366 or 16.3894 mills for most Windermere homes outside the town, and 16.2943 in the City of Winter Garden.
Town of Windermere, Windermere outside the town, and Winter Garden: the numbers
| Town of Windermere | Windermere outside the town (unincorporated, ZIP 34786) | City of Winter Garden | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homes on the tax roll | 1,195 single-family homes; no townhomes or condos | 13,570: 10,530 single-family homes, 2,350 townhomes, 690 condos | 14,874: 12,799 single-family homes, 1,259 townhomes, 816 condos |
| Median single-family sale price | $1,289,000 (49 sales) | $934,750 (432 sales) | $665,000 (497 sales) |
| Median price per sq ft (single-family) | $442 | $294 | $259 |
| Typical single-family home size | 3,288 sq ft | 3,048 sq ft | 2,443 sq ft |
| Typical single-family lot | 0.64 acre | 0.25 acre | 0.21 acre |
| Median townhome / condo sale price | — | Townhomes $390,000 (83 sales); condos $316,500 (32 sales) | Townhomes $272,500 (52 sales); condos $246,000 (36 sales) |
| Typical year built | 1989 (half the homes were built before 1990) | 2006 (34% built in 2010 or later) | 2005 (30% built in 2010 or later) |
| Local services tax rate (2025) | 3.7425 mills (town tax) | No town tax; instead 4.6480 mills of Orange County taxes for unincorporated areas: 1.8043 for the Sheriff and other county services and 2.8437 for fire rescue. Town and city homes do not pay these two; their police and fire are paid from the town or city tax. | 4.8565 mills (city tax) |
| Total property-tax rate (2025) | 15.4839 mills | 16.1366 mills (district 35, half the homes) or 16.3894 (district 75, 37%); 16.0858 to 16.9894 across all | 16.2943 mills |
| Tax on $500,000 of taxable value | About $7,742 a year | About $8,068 to $8,195 a year | About $8,147 a year |
Homes, sizes, lots, build years and prices: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 county tax roll, parcels inside each town's tax district; "Windermere outside the town" is every parcel with a Windermere 34786 address in an unincorporated Orange County tax district. Medians use qualified sales from July 2025 to June 2026. Tax rates: Orange County Property Appraiser, 2025 final millage rates. The tax example ignores exemptions such as homestead and assumes the town's main tax district (Windermere district 75; Winter Garden district 65, which covers most of the city).
Windermere outside the town limits
Most people who live in Windermere live outside the town limits, and they are just as much a part of Windermere: same mailing address, the same lakes, and the town's shops and parks close by. About 9 in 10 homes with a Windermere, FL 34786 address are in unincorporated Orange County. That includes Isleworth, Keene's Pointe, Lake Butler Sound and much of Horizon West. Of the 30-plus Windermere-address communities we track, only a few are confirmed inside the town limits, including The Manors, Chaine Du Lac, Willows at Lake Rhea and Marina Bay. The same applies to "Winter Garden" addresses: Horizon West communities such as Summerlake, Storey Grove and Waterleigh have Winter Garden mailing addresses but are in unincorporated Orange County.
What changes outside the town: Orange County governs instead of the Town Council, the Orange County Sheriff's Office patrols instead of the Windermere Police Department, and the home pays unincorporated county tax rates. In 2025, almost 9 in 10 Windermere homes outside the town were in two tax districts: district 35 (16.1366 mills in total) and district 75 (16.3894 mills). That is a little more than the town's 15.4839 mills, and about the same as the City of Winter Garden. Check the tax district on the property record for any home you are considering.
Home prices and home types
The Town of Windermere is made up of single-family homes on large lots, many near the Butler Chain of Lakes. Its median sale price is about twice Winter Garden's. Windermere outside the town has a much wider mix: guard-gated golf and lakefront estates, newer single-family homes (median $934,750), townhomes ($390,000) and condos ($316,500). Winter Garden offers a wider range: single-family homes at a median of $665,000, townhomes at $272,500 and condos at $246,000. That makes it easier to find an entry price there.
Older vs newer homes
Half of the homes in the Town of Windermere were built before 1990, and the typical home dates from 1989. Outside the town, the typical Windermere home was built in 2006, and 34% were built in 2010 or later, many of them in Horizon West. In Winter Garden, the typical home was built in 2005, and 30% were built in 2010 or later, as the city grew.
Property taxes
Florida property tax is the total millage rate times the taxable value. One mill is $1 per $1,000 of taxable value. The town or city rate is only one part; the school board, Orange County and other districts add the rest. In 2025, the total was 15.4839 mills in the Town of Windermere, 16.1366 or 16.3894 mills for most Windermere homes outside the town, and 16.2943 mills in most of Winter Garden. Homes outside the town pay no town tax; instead they pay two Orange County taxes for unincorporated areas, 1.8043 mills for the Sheriff and other county services and 2.8437 mills for fire rescue, 4.6480 mills in all. Homes in the Town of Windermere and the City of Winter Garden do not pay these two county taxes, because the town or city tax pays for their police and fire service. Homes in tax district 75, and all homes in the town, also pay 0.2528 mills to the Windermere water and navigation district for the Butler Chain of Lakes. On $500,000 of taxable value, that is about $7,742 a year in the town, $8,068 to $8,195 outside it, and $8,147 in Winter Garden, before any exemptions. For the next budget year, the Windermere Town Council kept its rate at 3.7425 mills, where it has been since 2018, and Winter Garden proposed keeping its rate at 4.8565 mills.
Here is every tax in the total, line by line:
| Tax (2025, mills) | Town of Windermere | Windermere outside the town | City of Winter Garden |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orange County (countywide) | 4.4347 | 4.4347 | 4.4347 |
| Orange County School Board | 6.4490 | 6.4490 | 6.4490 |
| Orange County Library District | 0.3748 | 0.3748 | 0.3748 |
| Water management district | 0.2301 (South Florida) | 0.2301 (South Florida) | 0.1793 (St. Johns River) |
| Town or city tax | 3.7425 | — | 4.8565 |
| County unincorporated services (Sheriff) | — | 1.8043 | — |
| County fire rescue | — | 2.8437 | — |
| Windermere Water and Navigation Control District | 0.2528 | 0.2528 (tax district 75 only) | — |
| Total | 15.4839 | 16.1366 (district 35) or 16.3894 (district 75) | 16.2943 |
Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, Comparison of Taxes Levied, Orange County, 2025–26 (county, special district and city rates); Orange County Property Appraiser, 2025 final millage rates (totals by tax district); South Florida and St. Johns River Water Management Districts, 2025–26 adopted rates. Each column adds up to the Property Appraiser’s total. CDD and HOA fees and non-ad valorem assessments are extra.
Which is right for you?
- Choose the Town of Windermere for an established, low-density town of single-family homes on large lots, close to the Butler Chain of Lakes, and you are comfortable with a higher entry price.
- Choose Winter Garden for more choice of home types and prices, and newer homes.
- Choose Windermere outside the town limits for the Windermere address with the most choice: gated golf and lakefront communities on the Butler Chain, newer homes in Horizon West, and townhomes. Most Windermere residents live here. Compare the tax district for each home.
Compare individual neighborhoods in our community comparison table, or read the Windermere and Winter Garden guides.
Frequently asked questions
Is Windermere more expensive than Winter Garden?
Yes. The median single-family sale price was $1,289,000 in the Town of Windermere, $934,750 in Windermere outside the town, and $665,000 in the City of Winter Garden (July 2025 – June 2026).
Are property taxes higher in Windermere or Winter Garden?
The total 2025 rate was lower in the Town of Windermere (15.4839 mills) than in the City of Winter Garden (16.2943 mills). Most Windermere homes outside the town paid 16.1366 or 16.3894 mills, about the same as Winter Garden.
Is my Windermere address inside the Town of Windermere?
Probably not, and that is normal. About 13,570 homes with a 34786 address are outside the town, against 1,195 inside it. The property's tax record shows its tax district.
Deciding between Windermere and Winter Garden? Contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256. We work in both every day.
Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 county tax roll for Orange County; Orange County Property Appraiser, 2025 final millage rates; Orange Observer (Winter Garden proposed millage, July 29, 2026; Windermere millage, August 5, 2026); U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder (town limits for individual communities).
