Sinkholes in Windermere, Winter Garden and Dr. Phillips: What the State Data Shows (2026)
Quick answer: The Florida Geological Survey’s statewide database lists 232 reported ground-subsidence incidents in Orange County from 1961 to August 2026. Inside the Town of Windermere there are 9, inside the City of Winter Garden 2, in Horizon West 5 and in the Dr. Phillips Census area none. The Windermere 34786 ZIP area has 14. These are unverified public reports, not confirmed sinkholes: none of the local reports is marked as a verified sinkhole. Every Florida homeowners policy must cover a catastrophic ground cover collapse, but broader sinkhole coverage is optional and costs extra.
This guide shows what the state’s own sinkhole data says for each area, what the numbers can and cannot tell you, how Florida insurance law treats sinkholes and what to check before you buy.
What the state data shows
We downloaded every record in the Florida Geological Survey (FGS) Subsidence Incident Reports layer on October 15, 2026 and counted the reports that fall inside each official Census boundary.
| Area | Reports | Years of dated reports | Marked as verified sinkhole |
|---|---|---|---|
| Town of Windermere | 9 | 1964 to 1981 (2 undated) | 0 |
| City of Winter Garden | 2 | 1982 | 0 |
| Horizon West (Census area) | 5 | 1981, 1982, 2012, 2022, 2025 | 0 |
| Dr. Phillips (Census area) | 0 | None inside; 6 within a mile of its edge | 0 |
| Windermere 34786 ZIP area | 14 | 1964 to 2019 (2 undated) | 0 |
| All of Orange County | 232 | 1961 to August 2026 (13 undated) | 3 |
Source: Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Florida Geological Survey, Subsidence Incident Reports (ArcGIS layer, all 4,457 records downloaded October 15, 2026). Boundaries: U.S. Census Bureau TIGERweb, 2020 Census incorporated places, census-designated places and ZIP Code Tabulation Area 34786; the January 2026 Census town, city and CDP boundaries give the same counts. Our point-in-boundary count, except the Orange County row, which uses the database’s County field (a boundary count also gives 232). The ZIP area overlaps the town and part of Horizon West, so rows do not add up.
Across Orange County, reports have come in at a slow, steady pace in recent years: 25 from 2016 through 2025, or about 2.5 a year, and 4 so far in 2026. The busiest decade on record was the 1980s, with 84 reports. Statewide, the database holds 4,457 reports, and Orange County has the seventh-highest count among Florida counties, behind Hillsborough, Marion, Citrus, Pasco, Hernando and Polk.
| Decade | Orange County reports |
|---|---|
| 1960s | 27 |
| 1970s | 12 |
| 1980s | 84 |
| 1990s | 21 |
| 2000s | 37 |
| 2010s | 18 |
| 2020 to August 2026 | 20 |
| No date recorded | 13 |
Source: Florida Geological Survey, Subsidence Incident Reports, records with County = Orange, downloaded October 15, 2026; grouped by event date (the date the feature was first observed and documented).
The big caveat: a report is not a confirmed sinkhole
The FGS says plainly that most of these incidents have not been field-checked and that the cause of the ground sinking is usually not known. A hole or dip in the ground can come from a true sinkhole, but it can also come from a broken sewer or drain pipe, a failed septic tank, soil that was not packed down after digging, compressing clay or buried logs and debris. In Orange County, only 3 of the 232 reports are marked as verified sinkholes, 6 are marked as not sinkholes and 223 are unverified.
- Reporting is voluntary. No law has ever required sinkholes or sinkhole insurance claims to be entered in this database, so it reflects who chose to report, not every event. Reports come from the State Watch Office, public report forms, emergency surveys and a small number of insurance claims.
- Many old locations are approximate. Of the 16 reports inside Windermere, Winter Garden and Horizon West, 11 carry a location code for a survey section, part of a section or a township, not a parcel or GPS point, so their mapped spots are approximate. A report shown just inside or outside a boundary may really sit on the other side.
- No record does not mean no risk. The Dr. Phillips Census area has no reports inside it, but 6 lie within a mile of its edge. The FGS says no part of Florida is technically free of sinkholes, because the whole state sits on carbonate rock.
The geology under west Orange County
Florida sits on limestone and similar rock. Rainwater is slightly acidic and grows more acidic as it passes through decaying plants. Over time it dissolves the rock and leaves underground voids. When the sand and clay above settle or fall into a void, a sinkhole forms. The FGS describes three types: solution sinkholes where rock is near the surface, cover-subsidence sinkholes that sink gradually through sandy cover, and cover-collapse sinkholes that open suddenly where less permeable, clayey cover sits over a void.
The 1985 statewide sinkhole-type map (Map Series 110, published by the U.S. Geological Survey with Florida’s state geology bureau and now served by the FGS) places most of this area in what it calls Area III: 30 to 200 feet of mostly clayey cover over the limestone, where sinkholes are most numerous, vary in size and develop abruptly, and cover-collapse sinkholes dominate. By our measurement of the mapped areas, all of Windermere, more than 99% of Winter Garden, about 99% of Dr. Phillips and about two-thirds of Horizon West fall in Area III. The rest of Horizon West falls in Area II, sandier cover where sinkholes are few, shallow, small and develop gradually. It is a small-scale 1985 statewide map and cannot tell you about a single lot.
Sources: FGS, About Florida Sinkholes and Sinkhole FAQ; FGS Sinkhole Types layer (digitized Map Series 110, 1985), area shares measured October 15, 2026.
How Florida insurance treats sinkholes
Section 627.706, Florida Statutes (2026), sets two different levels of protection. For the full picture of premiums and wind coverage, see our guide to homeowners insurance in Windermere and Winter Garden.
| Catastrophic ground cover collapse | Sinkhole loss coverage | |
|---|---|---|
| Required? | Yes, every Florida property insurer must include it | No; insurers must make it available for an extra premium |
| What it covers | Only when all four happen: the ground collapses abruptly, a depression is clearly visible, the building and foundation suffer structural damage, and the government condemns the home and orders it vacated | Structural damage to the building, including the foundation, caused by sinkhole activity, as defined in the statute |
| Cracks and settling alone | Not covered | Covered only if they meet the law’s definition of structural damage from sinkhole activity |
| Deductible | Not set by this statute; check the policy | May be 1%, 2%, 5% or 10% of the dwelling limit |
| Inspection first? | Not addressed; the coverage is required | The insurer may require one before it sells the coverage |
Source: Section 627.706, Florida Statutes (2026), viewed October 15, 2026; Florida Department of Financial Services, Sinkholes and Catastrophic Ground Cover Collapse consumer guide (February 2026).
Three more rules matter. Insurers may limit both coverages to the main house. A policy that leaves out sinkhole coverage must say so in bold type. And a sinkhole claim must be reported within 2 years after you knew, or should have known, about the damage. The Department of Financial Services adds that an insurer may decline sinkhole coverage if testing finds sinkhole activity on or near the property.
What a sinkhole inspection or geotechnical report is
A regular home inspection is not a sinkhole investigation. The FGS says home inspectors and insurance adjusters are not trained or qualified to decide whether there is a sinkhole, and no state agency inspects homes for sinkholes. The Department of Financial Services also notes that a standard 4-point inspection normally does not address sinkholes.
- Who does it: a licensed professional engineer or professional geologist. In an insurance claim, Florida law leaves the choice of tests to their professional judgment. A report you order before buying is a private engagement, but the same kind of professional does it.
- What the report says: in an insurance claim, section 627.7073 requires the report and certification to state whether there is structural damage, whether sinkhole activity caused it, which tests were performed and, if a sinkhole is confirmed, how to stabilize the land and repair the foundation.
- Public record: when an insurer pays a sinkhole claim, it must file the report and the amount paid with the county clerk for recording, and the engineer later files a certificate that repairs were done. In Orange County, official records are kept by the Orange County Comptroller. The law says a recorded report is not a lien or a title defect.
If you are looking at a house built decades ago, our checklist for buying an older home covers the other inspections worth ordering.
What sellers must disclose
In Johnson v. Davis (1985), the Florida Supreme Court held that a home seller who knows of facts that materially affect the value of the property, are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer must disclose them. Florida law adds a specific rule: if a seller made a sinkhole claim and the insurer paid it, the seller must tell the buyer before closing that the claim was paid and whether the full amount was used to repair the damage (section 627.7073).
A short checklist before you buy
- Ask the seller in writing about any sinkhole claim, testing or foundation repair.
- Search the Orange County official records for a recorded sinkhole report on the property.
- Ask your insurance agent early whether the home is insurable and whether the quote includes sinkhole coverage or only catastrophic ground cover collapse.
- If you see wall cracks, sloping floors or a depression in the yard, hire a professional engineer or geologist, not just a home inspector.
- Check the flood zone at the same time; our flood zone guide for Windermere, Winter Garden and Dr. Phillips shows how.
Frequently asked questions
How many sinkholes have been reported in Windermere?
The state database lists 9 reports inside the Town of Windermere, dated 1964 to 1981 plus 2 undated, and 14 in the wider 34786 ZIP area through 2019. None is marked as a verified sinkhole.
Are there sinkholes in Winter Garden or Horizon West?
Inside the City of Winter Garden the database lists 2 reports, both from 1982. Horizon West has 5, including reports in 2012, 2022 and 2025. All are unverified.
Has Dr. Phillips had sinkholes?
No report falls inside the Dr. Phillips Census boundary, but 6 lie within a mile of its edge.
Does my homeowners insurance cover sinkholes in Florida?
Every policy must cover a catastrophic ground cover collapse, which requires an abrupt, visible collapse, structural damage to the house and a government order to vacate it. Sinkhole loss coverage for structural damage is optional, costs extra and can carry a deductible of 1% to 10% of the dwelling limit.
Does a seller have to tell me about a sinkhole?
Yes, if the seller knows of it, it materially affects the value, and it is not easy to see or already known to you. A seller who received an insurance payment for a sinkhole claim must also say, before closing, whether all of it went to repairs.
Want help weighing a home’s inspection, insurance quote and records before you commit? Call Infinity Realty Group, LLC at 407-234-2256 or browse homes and streets on our Windermere community page.
This guide is general information, not legal, insurance or engineering advice. Ask a licensed professional engineer or geologist about a specific property and your insurance agent about coverage. All real estate guides
Sources: Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Florida Geological Survey, Subsidence Incident Reports ArcGIS layer (downloaded October 15, 2026); FGS, About Florida Sinkholes, Subsidence Incident Reports and Sinkhole FAQ pages (October 15, 2026); FGS Sinkhole Types layer, digitized from Map Series 110, Sinkhole Type, Development and Distribution in Florida (1985), with University of Florida GeoPlan Center metadata (October 15, 2026); U.S. Census Bureau, TIGERweb 2020 Census and January 2026 boundaries (October 15, 2026); sections 627.706, 627.707, 627.7072 and 627.7073, Florida Statutes (2026); Florida Department of Financial Services, Sinkholes and Catastrophic Ground Cover Collapse consumer guide (February 2026); Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), as quoted in The Florida Bar Journal (June 2004); Orange County Government directory, Official Records Department, County Comptroller (October 15, 2026).
