Isleworth vs Keene’s Pointe vs Lake Butler Sound: Windermere Luxury Communities Compared
Quick answer: All three are guard-gated luxury communities in the Windermere area, outside the Town of Windermere. Isleworth has the largest homes (typically about 6,190 sq ft), the largest lots and the highest prices: a $4.33 million median sale. Keene's Pointe is the biggest and most active, with 1,045 homes, 62 sales in the last year and a $1.53 million median. The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound sits between them at a $2.1 million median, with large homes, some Lake Butler frontage and no golf course.
Side by side
| Isleworth | Keene's Pointe | The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gate | Guard-gated | Guard-gated | Guard-gated |
| Single-family homes | 330 | 1,045 | 213 |
| Mostly built | 1988–2018 | 2000–2011 | 2003–2008 |
| Typical home size | 6,192 sq ft | 3,885 sq ft | 5,585 sq ft |
| Typical lot | 0.68 acre | 0.39 acre | 0.57 acre |
| Median sale price | $4,330,000 | $1,525,000 | $2,100,000 |
| Median price per sq ft | $745 | $428 | $416 |
| Sale price range | $2.36M – $11.5M | $775K – $13.2M | $1.34M – $6.8M |
| Qualified sales, Jul 2025 – Jun 2026 | 19 | 62 | 11 |
| Lakes | Butler Chain: Lake Bessie, Lake Louise, Lake Isleworth, Lake Butler and Lake Chase | Butler Chain of Lakes | Lake Butler (some homes) |
| Golf | Private Arnold Palmer course, Isleworth Golf & Country Club | Private Jack Nicklaus course, the Golden Bear Club (opened 1999) | No on-site course |
| Town limits | Unincorporated Orange County | Unincorporated Orange County | Unincorporated Orange County |
Counts, sizes, lots and prices: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 county tax roll, single-family homes only, qualified sales from July 2025 to June 2026. "Typical" means the median. Lakes and golf: the club websites and our community pages. Town limits: U.S. Census Bureau address lookup.
Isleworth
Isleworth is a 600-acre private golf community on the Butler Chain of Lakes, built around Isleworth Golf & Country Club. Arnold Palmer began the course and club in 1986, and Joe Lewis bought Isleworth in 1993. The club has a clubhouse, a tennis center and members-only docks.
It has the largest homes and lots of the three, and the highest price per square foot ($745). Sales in the last year ranged from $2.36 million to $11.5 million.
Our sales in Isleworth: 5300 Isleworth Country Club Dr and 9368 Blanche Cove.
Keene's Pointe
Keene's Pointe surrounds the private Golden Bear Club, whose Jack Nicklaus Signature course opened in 1999 on the Butler Chain of Lakes. Social membership adds tennis, a pool and a fitness center.
With 1,045 single-family homes, it has three times as many homes as Isleworth, and it had the most sales of the three. Homes are smaller on average (about 3,885 sq ft), but the price range is the widest: from $775,000 to $13.2 million. That makes it the most likely of the three to have something for sale at a given time.
The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound
The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound is a guard-gated community on Lake Butler, with 213 single-family homes built mostly from 2003 to 2008. Homes are large (about 5,585 sq ft) on lots of about 0.57 acre, and some have Lake Butler frontage. It has no golf course, so there is no club to join. It had the lowest price per square foot of the three ($416).
Our sales in Lake Butler Sound: in October 2026 we represented the seller of a 5-bedroom, 4,238 sq ft home on Rydal Court, which sold for $1,485,000.
Which one fits?
- For a private golf club at your door: Isleworth (Palmer) or Keene's Pointe (Nicklaus).
- For the widest choice of homes and price points: Keene's Pointe.
- For the largest homes and lots: Isleworth.
- For a large home on or near Lake Butler without a golf club: The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound.
Medians hide a lot: prices vary widely by street, lot size and view. For a specific street or home, ask us for a comparison of recent sales.
Frequently asked questions
Which is more expensive, Isleworth or Keene's Pointe?
Isleworth. Its median single-family sale price over the last year was $4,330,000, against $1,525,000 in Keene's Pointe. Isleworth homes are also larger: about 6,190 sq ft against 3,890 sq ft.
Are Isleworth, Keene's Pointe and Lake Butler Sound in the Town of Windermere?
No. All three have Windermere mailing addresses but are in unincorporated Orange County.
How does golf club membership work in Isleworth and Keene's Pointe?
Membership rules differ by club and change over time. Ask us, or the club, about the current rules for the home you are considering.
For what each budget buys across Windermere and Dr. Phillips, from $750,000 to more than $5 million, see what $1 million, $2 million and $5 million buy.
Comparing these communities for a move? Contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256 for a home-by-home comparison.
Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 county tax roll for Orange County; U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder; Isleworth Golf & Country Club (isleworth.com); LINKS Magazine (Isleworth history); The Golden Bear Club at Keene's Pointe; Nicklaus Design; GrowthSpotter (Lake Butler Sound).
