Home Prices by Neighborhood: Windermere, Winter Garden and Dr. Phillips (2026)

← All real estate guides

Quick answer: In the 50 Windermere, Winter Garden and Dr. Phillips communities we track, median single-family sale prices from mid-2025 to mid-2026 ranged from $495,000 in Wickham Park to $4,330,000 in Isleworth. The five highest were Isleworth ($4.33M), Casabella ($3.10M), Chaine Du Lac ($2.40M), Avalon Cove ($2.25M), The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound ($2.10M). Most Horizon West communities sold between $530,000 and $850,000 (17 of 21). For comparison, the median was $1,289,000 inside the Town of Windermere and $665,000 inside the City of Winter Garden.

This guide ranks neighborhoods by the median price of single-family homes that sold in the 12 months up to June 2026, the latest month in the 2026 county tax roll. A median is the middle sale: half sold for more and half for less. Townhome prices are in a separate table, because a townhome and a house in the same community sell for very different prices.

Median home prices by neighborhood

CommunityMailing city and areaMedian sale priceSalesTypical home size, sq ftSingle-family homesMostly built
1. IsleworthWindermere$4,330,000196,1923301988–2018
2. CasabellaWindermere$3,097,50066,757792015–2019
3. Chaine Du LacWindermere$2,400,0003 (few)5,961321995–2016
4. Avalon CoveWinter Garden (Horizon West)$2,254,0003 (few)4,436492021–2022
5. The Reserve at Lake Butler SoundWindermere$2,100,000115,5852132003–2008
6. Waterford PointeWindermere$2,075,0004 (few)4,1971141991–2004
7. Cypress PointDr. Phillips$1,970,00075,3621241991–1999
8. Kelso on Lake ButlerWindermere$1,865,0004 (few)4,105591977–2016
9. Keene's PointeWindermere$1,525,000623,8851,0452000–2011
10. WaterstoneWindermere$1,517,50084,6941202012–2017
11. Lake Burden SouthWindermere$1,350,00053,4611072008–2015
12. Phillips LandingDr. Phillips$1,196,00093,6673581997–2001
13. Tildens GroveWindermere$1,170,0003 (few)4,3981382002–2006
14. Hickory HammockWinter Garden$1,165,000233,5313852015–2018
15. Windermere IsleWindermere (Horizon West)$1,140,00053,3361162018–2019
16. South BayDr. Phillips$1,075,000113,488About 200 homes1981–1995
17. Sunset LakesWinter Garden$992,5004 (few)2,8201041993–2000
18. Oakland ParkWinter Garden$980,000352,6817192014–2024
19. GlenmuirWindermere$865,000103,0682272002–2003
20. Latham ParkWinter Garden (Horizon West)$845,00092,8243402016–2019
21. Westover ClubWindermere$831,25063,3901602001–2003
22. Bronson's LandingWinter Garden$825,00053,7661232007–2009
23. Windermere DownsWindermere$825,000112,9782041977–1998
24. Wintermere HarborWinter Garden$800,0003 (few)2,876912000–2002
25. ProvidenceWindermere (Horizon West)$774,50082,8262162003–2005
26. Carriage Pointe & Reserve at Carriage PointeWinter Garden$772,500132,8812752007–2014
27. Windermere CrossingWinter Garden$755,0003 (few)3,0021532000–2001
28. Johns Lake PointeWinter Garden$740,000133,1643122011–2016
29. Highlands at Summerlake GrovesWinter Garden (Horizon West)$739,000112,6133032016–2020
30. Windermere TrailsWindermere (Horizon West)$716,250243,0386472013–2017
31. WatermarkWinter Garden (Horizon West)$702,500342,2047292015–2020
32. WaterleighWinter Garden (Horizon West)$688,1001262,4771,9052017–2024
33. Lake Sawyer SouthWindermere (Horizon West)$682,500162,6084142007–2012
34. Sand Lake PointDr. Phillips$675,000122,4034301988–1997
35. VineyardsWindermere (Horizon West)$637,5004 (few)2,724912014–2019
36. The Enclave at HamlinWinter Garden (Horizon West)$635,0003 (few)2,459932020–2022
37. HawksmoorWinter Garden (Horizon West)$630,00072,4702722019–2021
38. Stoneybrook WestWinter Garden$622,500462,5051,2092001–2008
39. Johns LandingOakland$600,000153,1902612001–2005
40. SummerlakeWinter Garden (Horizon West)$597,500562,6681,2552013–2018
41. Orchard HillsWinter Garden (Horizon West)$595,000172,8145772014–2018
42. SummerportWindermere (Horizon West)$595,000242,6188282004–2006
43. Orchard ParkWinter Garden (Horizon West)$595,000112,5601962016–2019
44. Wintermere PointeWinter Garden$580,00092,9012011999–2004
45. Del Webb OasisWinter Garden (Horizon West)$575,000412,0283702023–2025
46. Lakes of WindermereWindermere (Horizon West)$567,500282,4607852003–2008
47. Alexander RidgeWinter Garden$539,25062,5621962014–2016
48. Lakeview PointeWinter Garden (Horizon West)$538,750142,3682442016–2018
49. Storey GroveWinter Garden (Horizon West)$527,500202,4865552017–2023
50. Wickham ParkWindermere (Horizon West)$495,00061,696562007–2012

Source: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 county tax roll for Orange County. Single-family homes only. Qualified (arm's-length) sales, mostly July 2025 to June 2026; each community page shows its exact months. "Few" means fewer than 5 sales, so treat that median as a rough guide. "Typical home size" is the median living area of all single-family homes in the community, not only the ones that sold.

Neighborhoods by price range

$2 million and up (6 communities)

Isleworth ($4.33M), Casabella ($3.10M), Chaine Du Lac ($2.40M), Avalon Cove ($2.25M), The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound ($2.10M), Waterford Pointe ($2.08M).

$1 million to $2 million (10 communities)

Cypress Point ($1.97M), Kelso on Lake Butler ($1.86M), Keene's Pointe ($1.53M), Waterstone ($1.52M), Lake Burden South ($1.35M), Phillips Landing ($1.20M), Tildens Grove ($1.17M), Hickory Hammock ($1.17M), Windermere Isle ($1.14M), South Bay ($1.07M).

$700,000 to $1 million (15 communities)

Sunset Lakes ($992K), Oakland Park ($980K), Glenmuir ($865K), Latham Park ($845K), Westover Club ($831K), Bronson's Landing ($825K), Windermere Downs ($825K), Wintermere Harbor ($800K), Providence ($774K), Carriage Pointe & Reserve at Carriage Pointe ($772K), Windermere Crossing ($755K), Johns Lake Pointe ($740K), Highlands at Summerlake Groves ($739K), Windermere Trails ($716K), Watermark ($702K).

Under $700,000 (19 communities)

Waterleigh ($688K), Lake Sawyer South ($682K), Sand Lake Point ($675K), Vineyards ($638K), The Enclave at Hamlin ($635K), Hawksmoor ($630K), Stoneybrook West ($622K), Johns Landing ($600K), Orchard Hills ($595K), Summerport ($595K), Orchard Park ($595K), Summerlake ($584K), Wintermere Pointe ($580K), Del Webb Oasis ($575K), Lakes of Windermere ($568K), Alexander Ridge ($539K), Lakeview Pointe ($539K), Storey Grove ($528K), Wickham Park ($495K).

Town of Windermere and City of Winter Garden

A Windermere or Winter Garden mailing address does not mean the home is inside that town. Inside the Town of Windermere limits, the median single-family sale price was $1,289,000 (49 sales). Inside the City of Winter Garden limits, it was $665,000 (497 sales). Most of the communities above are in unincorporated Orange County. Read more in Windermere vs Winter Garden.

Horizon West

Horizon West is the newer, planned part of southwest Orange County, with Windermere and Winter Garden mailing addresses. Of the 21 Horizon West communities with enough sales, 17 had a median between $530,000 and $850,000. The exceptions were Avalon Cove ($2.25M), Windermere Isle ($1.14M) and Wickham Park ($495K).

Townhome prices

17 of the communities we track have townhomes with enough sales to show a median. They sold from $342,500 to $458,900.

CommunityMailing city and areaMedian townhome sale priceSalesTownhomesTypical townhome size, sq ft
Windermere TrailsWindermere (Horizon West)$458,9003 (few)1201,760
SummerlakeWinter Garden (Horizon West)$455,000121781,853
VineyardsWindermere (Horizon West)$435,00091921,978
Highlands at Summerlake GrovesWinter Garden (Horizon West)$430,0005521,868
Lake Burden SouthWindermere$425,000112251,881
HawksmoorWinter Garden (Horizon West)$422,500101871,792
WaterleighWinter Garden (Horizon West)$417,000354721,568
Storey GroveWinter Garden (Horizon West)$408,000113331,717
WatermarkWinter Garden (Horizon West)$406,50051191,789
Hickory HammockWinter Garden$405,00051001,902
Winding Bay PreserveWinter Garden (Horizon West)$400,0004 (few)871,868
Wickham ParkWindermere (Horizon West)$390,000112451,540
Lakeview PointeWinter Garden (Horizon West)$389,7504 (few)701,624
Stoneybrook WestWinter Garden$385,00051841,838
Lake Sawyer SouthWindermere (Horizon West)$385,00061401,680
SummerportWindermere (Horizon West)$370,00092521,516
Lakes of WindermereWindermere (Horizon West)$342,500133821,429

Source: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 county tax roll. A townhome here is a single-family-use parcel that the county codes as a townhouse. Condos are not included.

How to use these numbers

  • A median is not a price for one home. Lot size, lake frontage, age and condition change prices a lot inside one community. Isleworth sales, for example, ranged from $2.36 million to $11.5 million in the same year.
  • Small samples move a lot. A community with 3 or 4 sales can show a very different median next year.
  • Tax-roll data lags. The 2026 roll includes sales up to June 2026. For a current price, ask for a comparison of recent sales on the street you are considering.
  • Some communities have no median here. We show a median only when a community has at least 3 qualified sales. Bay Hill, Orange Tree, Turtle Creek and Vizcaya are among those without one.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most expensive neighborhood in Windermere, FL?

Isleworth. Its median single-family sale price was $4,330,000 (19 sales, July 2025 to May 2026), the highest of the communities we track. Casabella ($3,097,500) and Chaine Du Lac ($2,400,000) were next.

What is the median home price in Winter Garden, FL?

Inside the City of Winter Garden limits, the median single-family sale price was $665,000 (497 sales, July 2025 to June 2026). Winter Garden-address communities in Horizon West mostly sold between $530,000 and $850,000.

Where can I buy a single-family home under $600,000 near Windermere?

In our data, communities with a median under $600,000 include Orchard Hills, Summerport, Orchard Park, Summerlake, Wintermere Pointe, Del Webb Oasis, Lakes of Windermere, Alexander Ridge, Lakeview Pointe, Storey Grove, Wickham Park. Most are in Horizon West. A median under $600,000 means about half the homes sold for less.

What is the most expensive neighborhood in Dr. Phillips?

Of the Dr. Phillips communities with enough sales, Cypress Point had the highest median: $1,970,000 (7 sales). Phillips Landing was $1,196,000, South Bay $1,075,000 and Sand Lake Point $675,000.

How current are these prices?

They use the 2026 Florida tax roll, which includes qualified sales up to June 2026. We update them every April and October.

For the upper end of the market by price band, including lot size and lakefront share, read what $1M, $2M and $5M buy in Windermere and Dr. Phillips.

Want a price for a specific home or street? Contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256. Thinking of selling? See how we set a list price or estimate what your home is worth.

All real estate guides

Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 county tax roll for Orange County (assessment roll GIS data); U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder (town limits for individual communities).