Gated Communities in Windermere, FL: 17 Neighborhoods Compared (2026)

← All real estate guides

Quick answer: We track 16 gated and 1 partly gated communities with a Windermere, FL address. Six have a staffed or guard gate: Isleworth, Keene's Pointe, Waterstone (24-hour manned gate), The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound, Waterford Pointe and Bellaria. Over the last 12 months of county records, median single-family sale prices ranged from $831,250 in Westover Club to $4,330,000 in Isleworth. Only one of these communities, Chaine Du Lac, is inside the Town of Windermere. The others are in unincorporated Orange County.

Windermere gated communities compared

CommunityGateLakeGolfHomesMostly builtMedian single-family sale priceIn Town of Windermere?
IsleworthGuard-gatedYesYes, private club3301988–2018$4,330,000 (19 sales)No
The Reserve at Lake Butler SoundGuard-gatedYes—2132003–2008$2,100,000 (11 sales)No
Waterford PointeGuard-gatedLake Roberts—1141991–2004$2,075,000 (4 sales)No
Keene's PointeGuard-gatedYesYes, private club1,0452000–2011$1,525,000 (62 sales)No
Waterstone24-hour guard gateSome homes on Lake Butler; central pond—1202012–2017$1,517,500 (8 sales)No
BellariaGuard-gatedNo lakefront lots; ponds, and small Lake Clarice borders community land—642007–2015—No
CasabellaGated entrancePond and water views—792015–2019$3,097,500 (6 sales)No
Chaine Du LacGated entranceLake Butler frontage—321995–2016$2,400,000 (3 sales)Yes
Tildens GroveGated entrance——1382002–2006$1,170,000 (3 sales)No
GlenmuirGated entrance——2272002–2003$865,000 (10 sales)No
Westover ClubGated entrance——1602001–2003$831,250 (6 sales)No
Casa Del LagoGated entranceLake Burden frontage—882011–2018—No
Oxford MoorGated entrance——832002–2005—No
The Estates at WindermereGated entrance——661996–2001—No
Westover ReserveGated entrance——781997–2001—No
Windermere ClubGated entranceSome waterfront estatesFormer course, closed 2016148 custom homes1——Not confirmed
Windermere Landing & EnclavePartly: Landing no, Enclave yes—————No

Homes, build years and prices come from the Florida Department of Revenue 2026 county tax roll. The median uses qualified single-family sales from July 2025 to June 2026 and is shown only where there were 3 or more sales. "In Town of Windermere?" comes from a U.S. Census address lookup. Gate status comes from our own community review and HOA sources. A dash means the fact is not a main feature or we have not confirmed it.

Guard-gated vs. gated: what is the difference?

A guard-gated community has staff at the entrance who check visitors. Hours vary. Waterstone's HOA states that its gate is manned 24 hours a day. A gated community controls entry with a gate, code, card or remote, but may have no staff. Partly gated means one section has a gate and another does not. Gate rules and staffing change over time, so we confirm the current entrance details for every buyer.

Guard-gated communities

Isleworth

Isleworth has 330 single-family homes on the county roll, mostly built from 1988 to 2018, on lakes of the Butler Chain including Lake Bessie, Lake Louise, Lake Isleworth, Lake Butler and Lake Chase. It is built around the private Isleworth Golf & Country Club. It has the highest median sale price on this list: $4,330,000 across 19 sales.

Keene's Pointe

Keene's Pointe is the largest community on this list, with 1,045 single-family homes, mostly built from 2000 to 2011. It surrounds the private Golden Bear Club and its Jack Nicklaus golf course, which opened in 1999. It also had the most sales: 62, at a median of $1,525,000.

Waterstone

Waterstone has 120 single-family homes on 128 acres, with a 24-hour manned gate, according to its HOA. Most homes were built from 2012 to 2017. It has a large central pond, and some homes front Lake Butler. Median sale price: $1,517,500 across 8 sales.

The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound

The Lake Butler Sound development has 213 single-family homes, mostly built from 2003 to 2008, and some homes have frontage on Lake Butler. Median sale price: $2,100,000 across 11 sales.

Waterford Pointe and Bellaria

Waterford Pointe has 114 homes, mostly built from 1991 to 2004, and some lots front Lake Roberts (median $2,075,000, 4 sales). Bellaria is a Toll Brothers community of 64 homes built mostly from 2007 to 2015, near the Butler Chain of Lakes. It had too few sales in the last 12 months to show a median.

Gated communities with a controlled entrance

  • Casabella: 79 homes built mostly 2015–2019; median $3,097,500 (6 sales).
  • Chaine Du Lac: 32 homes, some on Lake Butler coves; the only community on this list inside the Town of Windermere; median $2,400,000 (3 sales).
  • Tildens Grove: 138 homes built mostly 2002–2006; median $1,170,000 (3 sales).
  • Glenmuir: 227 homes built 2002–2003; median $865,000 (10 sales).
  • Westover Club: 160 homes built mostly 2001–2003; median $831,250 (6 sales).
  • Casa Del Lago, Oxford Moor, Westover Reserve and The Estates at Windermere: smaller gated enclaves of 66 to 88 homes with too few recent sales for a median.
  • Windermere Club: 148 custom homes behind a private gated entry. Its former golf course closed in April 2016.

Partly gated communities

In Windermere Landing & Enclave, Windermere Landing is not gated, while the Enclave at Windermere Landing is gated.

Gated and on the water

Gated communities with lake frontage or lake access include Isleworth and Keene's Pointe (Butler Chain of Lakes), Waterstone, Chaine Du Lac and The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound (Lake Butler), Waterford Pointe (Lake Roberts), and Casa Del Lago (Lake Burden). Frontage is usually limited to some lots, so check the specific home.

Gated golf communities

Two Windermere gated communities have an operating private golf club: Isleworth (Isleworth Golf & Country Club, an Arnold Palmer design) and Keene's Pointe (the Golden Bear Club, a Jack Nicklaus design). Membership rules differ by club, so ask about them for the home you are considering. Windermere Club's course closed in 2016.

Most are outside the Town of Windermere. Why does that matter?

A Windermere, FL 34786 mailing address does not mean a home is inside the Town of Windermere. Of the 17 communities above, only Chaine Du Lac is inside the town limits. Town residents pay the town's 3.7425-mill tax rate, and homes in unincorporated Orange County pay county service taxes instead. In 2025, total property-tax rates were 15.2311 to 15.4839 mills inside the Town of Windermere and 16.0858 to 19.0858 mills in unincorporated Orange County, depending on the tax district. Your exact district is on the property's tax record.

Gated communities nearby

In Dr. Phillips: Isle of Osprey, Phillips Landing, Vizcaya, Turtle Creek, Cypress Point and Orange Tree. In Winter Garden: Stoneybrook West, Hickory Hammock, Del Webb Oasis (55+) and others. See the full community comparison table.

Frequently asked questions

Which Windermere communities are guard-gated?

Isleworth, Keene's Pointe, Waterstone (24-hour manned gate), The Reserve at Lake Butler Sound, Waterford Pointe and Bellaria.

What is the most expensive gated community in Windermere?

By median single-family sale price over the last 12 months of county records, Isleworth: $4,330,000 across 19 sales. Casabella ($3,097,500) and Chaine Du Lac ($2,400,000) follow.

Which gated community in Windermere has the most homes?

Keene's Pointe, with 1,045 single-family homes on the 2026 county tax roll.

Are any gated communities inside the Town of Windermere?

Of the communities we track, Chaine Du Lac is the one gated community inside the town limits. The others have Windermere mailing addresses but are in unincorporated Orange County.

Looking at a specific gated community? We confirm the current gate, HOA and lake details for every buyer. Contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256.

All real estate guides

Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 county tax roll for Orange County (homes, build years, sales); U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder (town limits); Orange County Property Appraiser, 2025 final millage rates; Orange Observer (Windermere Country Club closure, 2018); HOA and club websites (Waterstone Community Association, Isleworth Golf & Country Club, The Golden Bear Club at Keene's Pointe). Each community page lists its own sources.