What It Costs to Own in Sunset Lakes and Banana Bay (2026)

Quick answer: A homestead buyer at Sunset Lakes' $992,500 median sale would owe about $15,200 in 2026 property tax, more than twice the $6,451 the typical homesteaded owner paid in 2025. In Banana Bay, about $11,650 at $770,000 against $5,672. Add $746 or $664 in county charges. There is no CDD, no lake levy and no county sewer bill.

Sunset Lakes and Banana Bay are neighboring 1990s communities near Lake Luntz with Winter Garden 34787 addresses, both in unincorporated Orange County rather than the City of Winter Garden. Our community pages have the basics on Sunset Lakes homes and Banana Bay real estate. This article answers what owning one costs each year, using the state's 2026 tax roll for every home, the Orange County Property Appraiser's certified 2025 taxes and 2026 charges for 40 Sunset Lakes homes and all 28 in Banana Bay, and its 2026 proposed tax rates.

The gap between what owners pay and what a buyer will

Almost everyone here has owned for years. On the 2026 roll, 91 of Sunset Lakes' 104 homes and 22 of Banana Bay's 28 have a homestead exemption, and Florida's Save Our Homes rule has held their assessed values down: the yearly rise is capped at 3% or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower (Florida Statutes section 193.155). After a sale, the assessment resets to market value the next January.

Sunset LakesBanana Bay
Median market value on the 2026 roll$766,480$728,605
Median homestead assessed at56% of market value59% of market value
Median gap between market and assessed value, homesteads$326,173$329,932
Homesteads assessed at under half of market value6 of 919 of 22
2025 tax paid, median homestead in our sample$6,451 (34 homes)$5,672 (24 homes)
2025 tax paid, median non-homestead$12,564 (6 homes)4 homes; too few

Market and assessed values (school assessed value), homestead status: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 Orange County tax roll, all homes. 2025 taxes: Orange County Property Appraiser, certified 2025 property taxes (ad valorem only, before county charges and any early-payment discount) for 40 Sunset Lakes homes, evenly spaced through the parcel list, and all 28 Banana Bay homes; homestead as shown on each record. Checked October 29, 2026.

That roughly $330,000 gap is the main cost fact in both neighborhoods. A seller's tax bill tells you what a long-time owner pays, not what you will pay. The six non-homestead Sunset Lakes homes in our sample, which have no homestead exemption and no 3% cap, are a better guide: their median 2025 bill was $12,564.

A buyer's first full year

Price2026 tax with homesteadWithout homestead
$750,000About $11,330About $11,990
$770,000 (Banana Bay, median of 3 sales, July 2024 to June 2026)About $11,650About $12,300
$992,500 (Sunset Lakes, median of 4 sales, July 2025 to June 2026)About $15,210About $15,860
$1,125,000 (Sunset Lakes, median of 5 sales, July 2024 to June 2026)About $17,320About $17,980

Sales: Florida Department of Revenue 2026 tax roll, qualified sales (codes 01 and 02, both sale slots). Sunset Lakes' four sales in the latest year were $750,000, $860,000, $1,125,000 and $1,250,000; with a $1,350,000 sale in May 2025 the two-year median is $1,125,000. Banana Bay's three sales over two years were $747,000, $770,000 and $1,100,000. Illustration only, assuming the assessed value equals the price, at the 2026 proposed rate of 15.9798 mills: school taxes of 6.343 mills on the value less $25,000 and the other 9.6368 mills on the value less $51,411 with a homestead; the full rate on the full value without. Checked October 29, 2026.

With so few sales, the medians are rough guides; lake frontage moves the price more than anything else here. Use the rule of thumb instead: with a homestead, each $100,000 of price adds about $1,600 a year in tax. Our article on how the property tax changes after you buy explains the reset in detail. If you are selling a Florida homestead, part of its Save Our Homes difference may be portable; see our homestead portability explainer. A home that will not be your homestead gets no homestead exemption, and after the first year its non-school assessment can rise by up to 10% a year (section 193.1554).

The tax rate: district 65

All 132 homes are in Orange County tax district 65, with a 2026 proposed total of 15.9798 mills. It differs from most of nearby Horizon West, district 35 at 16.0306 mills, in a single line: these homes fall in the St. Johns River Water Management District (0.1793 mill) rather than the South Florida district (0.2301). On $750,000 of taxable value that is about $38 a year less. The rest is the same: 6.343 mills for schools, 4.4347 for the county general fund, 2.8437 for county fire, 1.8043 for the unincorporated taxing district and 0.3748 for the library. There is no city tax, and unlike the Butler Chain communities, no Windermere water and navigation district levy. Our Orange County property tax guide for buyers explains each one.

County fees on the bill

2026 feeSunset LakesBanana Bay
Garbage collection$430.00$430.00
Stormwater (retention ponds)$78.00$78.00
Street lights$238.14$155.60
Total$746.14$663.60

Orange County Property Appraiser, 2026 non-ad valorem assessments; identical on all 40 Sunset Lakes sample homes and all 28 Banana Bay homes. Checked October 29, 2026.

No home in either community is in a community development district. Orange County's parcel map, which names the CDD for parcels that are in one, shows none for all 132 homes, and none of the 68 records we pulled carries a CDD line or a lake-management charge. Lake Roper, Lake Luntz and the ponds have no special levy on these bills.

Costs that are not on the tax bill

Septic and wells instead of a utility bill

As our Sunset Lakes vs. Banana Bay comparison found, every classified home in both communities is on a septic system, and most use a private well. That means no county sewer bill, and often no water bill, but the owner pays to maintain both: periodic septic pumping and inspection, the well pump and any water treatment. For a 1990s home, ask the seller for pumping and repair records, and budget for a septic inspection and a well-water test before closing. Our septic, well and sewer guide explains what to check.

Homeowners association dues

Each community has its own association, which owns the common land and lake tracts on the tax roll: the Sunset Lakes of Windermere Homeowners Association, which holds a 30-acre tract on Lake Roper, and the Banana Bay Homeowners Association. Neither publishes its dues or budget on a public site we could find. Listing sites give figures that do not agree, so we leave them out. The seller must give you a disclosure summary stating the current assessment before you sign (Florida Statutes section 720.401), and the association's estoppel certificate lists what is owed before closing (section 720.30851). With large lake tracts to maintain, ask too for the reserve schedule and whether any special assessment is planned. Our guide to HOA documents to get before buying lists the rest.

Insurance

Most homes here are about 26 to 36 years old, and insurers price roof age and system age closely. Get a quote on the address early, and check the flood map: in our comparison, 47 of 104 Sunset Lakes lots and 14 of 28 Banana Bay lots touch a FEMA high-risk flood zone, though no lot center falls inside one. Our homeowners insurance guide covers what drives the premium.

Frequently asked questions

How much are property taxes in Sunset Lakes?

Homesteaded owners in our sample paid a median of $6,451 in 2025. A buyer with a homestead at the $992,500 median sale would pay about $15,200 at the 2026 proposed rate, plus $746.14 in county charges.

Why are Banana Bay's tax bills so low?

Most homes have been homesteaded for years, so their assessed values are capped well below market value: the median homestead is assessed at 59% of it. The cap ends when a home sells.

Do Sunset Lakes or Banana Bay have a CDD or lake tax?

No. County records show no CDD for any of the 132 homes, and the 2026 tax records carry no lake charge.

Do these homes pay a sewer bill?

Not to the county: the homes are on septic systems, and most draw water from private wells, so maintenance of both falls on the owner.

Are Sunset Lakes and Banana Bay in the City of Winter Garden?

No. Both are in unincorporated Orange County, tax district 65, with Winter Garden mailing addresses.

Looking at a home in Sunset Lakes or Banana Bay? We can estimate your first-year tax at the price you have in mind, pull the home's tax record and line up septic, well and association documents before you offer. Contact Infinity Realty Group, LLC or call 407-234-2256.

This article is general information from public records, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Tax figures are estimates until the November 2026 bill is issued, and exemptions depend on your situation. Confirm taxes with the Orange County Property Appraiser and Tax Collector, dues with the association, and septic, well and insurance details for a specific home; ask a Florida attorney or tax adviser about your own case.

Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll via the Florida Geographic Information Office statewide cadastral service (homes, sales, values, exemptions, tax district; checked October 29, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser, certified 2025 property taxes and 2026 non-ad valorem assessments for 68 homes (checked October 29, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser, 2026 Proposed Millage Rates (printed August 10, 2026); Orange County GIS, AGOL Open Data parcels layer, CDD field (checked October 29, 2026); Florida Statutes sections 193.155, 193.1554, 720.401 and 720.30851 (2025 Florida Statutes, checked October 29, 2026); septic, well, flood and lake-tract findings as published in our Sunset Lakes vs. Banana Bay comparison and lakefront lots article (October 2026).