Buying a 2010s Builder Home in Horizon West: Roofs, Stucco, Warranties and the CDD

Quick answer: On a 2010s builder home in Horizon West, check four things: the roof's age against Florida's 15-year insurance line, the stucco and what is behind it, what is left of the builder's warranty, and the tax bill for a CDD. Most homes built in 2018 or earlier are now past Florida's 7-year limit for construction-defect suits, so the inspection carries more weight than the warranty.

Thousands of homes in Horizon West and next door in Winter Garden were built by national builders from 2013 to 2020, and many of them are now on their second or third owner. Four neighborhoods show the range: Summerlake, built by several builders, mostly from 2013 to 2018; homes in Waterleigh, all built by D.R. Horton from 2014 on; Storey Grove real estate, a Lennar neighborhood built from 2016 to 2025; and Hickory Hammock, built from 2014 to 2020 inside the City of Winter Garden rather than in Horizon West. This guide uses the 2026 Florida tax roll, Orange County's records, the builders' and associations' own documents and the Florida Statutes to answer one question: what changes when the house you are buying was built by a builder ten years ago, not last year? For the choice between a new home and a resale, see our new construction vs. resale comparison; this guide assumes you have already picked the resale.

How old these homes really are

The tax roll records the year each home was built. That year is the starting point for almost everything below: the roof's age for insurance, the builder's warranty and the legal deadline for a defect claim.

CommunityHomesBuiltBuilt 2014 or earlierBuilt 2015 to 2018Built 2019Built 2020 or later
Summerlake1,4332009 to 2021; median 2016385998491
Hickory Hammock4852014 to 2020; median 20164242698
Waterleigh2,3772014 to 2025; median 202036502171,507
Storey Grove8882016 to 2025; median 2020None215141532

Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll, single-family homes and townhomes in each community's plats, by year built. Checked October 28, 2026.

Summerlake and Hickory Hammock are the older pair: almost every home there was built by 2018. Waterleigh and Storey Grove are younger, with a median build year of 2020, though each has a few hundred homes from 2015 to 2018. That split decides which of the sections below matters most for the home you are looking at.

Who built the homes, and why it matters

The builder tells you which warranty booklet came with the home and whom to contact about a defect. Orange County's plat records name a developer for each section, and the Property Appraiser's sales history names the first seller of each home, which for a builder home is the builder. We sampled homes in every section of each community:

CommunityDeveloper on the recorded platsFirst seller of sampled homes
WaterleighD.R. Horton, all 14 residential plats (2014 to 2024)D.R. Horton on 350 of 350
Storey GroveLennar Homes, all 13 plats (2016 to 2022)Lennar on 72 of 72
SummerlakeSLV Summerlake (Starwood Land Ventures) on most plats; Lennar Homes on Phases 3A to 3CKB Home 144, D.R. Horton 83, Lennar 57, M/I Homes 37, Beazer Homes 27, K. Hovnanian 5, CalAtlantic 4, others 18 (375 sampled)
Hickory HammockRyland Group (2014 to 2015) and CalAtlantic Group (2016), on the plats that name a companyM/I Homes 32, CalAtlantic 24, Ryland 14 (70 sampled)

Orange County GIS Subdivision layer (developer and recording date of each plat); Orange County Property Appraiser sales histories, seller on the earliest recorded sale of each sampled home (company names only). Checked October 28, 2026. Samples, not a full count.

In Waterleigh and Storey Grove one builder did everything, so one set of plans, one construction method and one warranty program applies. In Summerlake and Hickory Hammock it depends on the block. Two houses on the same street can come from different builders, with different warranty books, so confirm the builder for the specific address from the sales history on the Property Appraiser's site before you rely on anything in this guide about warranties.

The roof: the 15-year line

For a 2010s home, the roof is usually the first big-ticket question, because insurance decides it. Under section 627.7011(5) of the Florida Statutes, an insurer may not refuse to write or renew a homeowners policy solely because a roof is less than 15 years old. Once a roof reaches 15, the insurer must let you have it inspected, at your expense, before it can require a replacement, and if the inspection shows at least five years of useful life left, it may not refuse the policy on age alone. The roof's age runs from the last date the whole roof was built or replaced. Our article on buying a home with an older roof covers those rules and Citizens Property Insurance's own limits in detail.

Applied to these four communities, assuming each roof is original:

  • Summerlake: the 385 homes built in 2014 or earlier reach 15 years by 2029, and 792 homes, more than half, by 2031.
  • Hickory Hammock: 42 homes reach 15 by 2029 and 325, two-thirds, by 2031.
  • Waterleigh: only 3 homes reach 15 by 2029 and 215 by 2031; the median home does not get there until 2035.
  • Storey Grove: no home reaches 15 before 2031, and the median not until 2035.

If you buy a 2014 Summerlake house today and plan to keep it seven years, expect the roof question to come up during your ownership even if it does not come up at closing. Three things make it easier:

  • Find the real age. A roof replaced after a storm resets the clock. Search the permit history: Orange County's permits are online through its Fast Track service for Summerlake, Waterleigh and Storey Grove, and the City of Winter Garden issues permits for Hickory Hammock. A reroof permit with a passed final inspection is the evidence an insurer and a wind mitigation inspector want.
  • The 25% rule no longer forces a full roof. Under section 553.844(5), if a roof was built or replaced to the 2007 Florida Building Code or later, repairing or replacing 25% or more of it requires only the repaired part to meet the current code. Every home in these four communities was built after 2007, so a storm repair on an original roof here should not, by that rule alone, force a whole new roof.
  • Ask the association first. Most associations treat a roof replacement as an exterior change that needs approval. Summerlake's Community Standards, amended September 25, 2024, require approval for any roof replacement, a minimum 5/12 pitch, and metal, asphalt, tile or a similar long-life material. Ask for the current standards of the home's association before you sign a roofing contract.

Stucco: what the code requires and what an inspection can see

Almost every home in these neighborhoods has a stucco exterior, known in the building code as exterior plaster. The current Florida Building Code, Residential (8th edition, 2023), section R703.7, requires it to be installed to ASTM C926, ASTM C1063 or ASTM C1787, with corrosion-resistant lath, a weep screed at least 4 inches above the earth or 2 inches above paving, and, where the stucco goes over wood-based sheathing, a water-resistive barrier at least equal to two layers of Grade D paper. Those details matter because the trouble spots in stucco are where water gets behind it: around windows and doors, at the base of the wall and where a roof meets a wall.

The construction behind the stucco matters too. Stucco applied directly to concrete block is a different system from stucco on lath over a wood-framed wall, and many two-story builder homes combine the two. D.R. Horton currently advertises "All Concrete Block Construction" for its Waterleigh homes; for an older home, ask the seller or your inspector which walls are block and which are frame.

What a standard inspection can and cannot tell you:

  • A general home inspection is visual. Florida law defines it as a limited visual examination of readily accessible components. It will report cracks, stains and missing caulk, but it cannot see water damage behind a sound-looking wall.
  • Hairline cracks are common. D.R. Horton's current warranty booklet calls hairline cracks in stucco common and covers only cracks wider than 1/8 inch, and only in the first year.
  • Go further if you see signs. Wide or stepped cracks, stains below windows, bubbling paint, soft spots or a musty room are reasons to ask a stucco or building-envelope specialist for moisture testing before your inspection period ends.

Our guide to the inspections Orlando buyers need explains the timing inside a Florida contract, and our 4-point and wind mitigation article covers the insurance forms.

What is left of the builder's warranty

National builders usually sell new homes with a written limited warranty in three tiers. The only one we could read in full, as published by the builder, is D.R. Horton's, which applies to Waterleigh. Its current booklet, administered by Residential Warranty Company (form 319, revised July 2025), says:

CoverageHow longWhat it coversWho stands behind it
Workmanship and materials1 year from the warranty's effective dateItems listed in the Year 1 standards, such as stucco cracks over 1/8 inch and active roof leaksThe builder
Systems2 yearsSpecified parts of the heating, cooling, ventilating, electrical and plumbing systemsThe builder
Major structural defects10 yearsActual damage to load-bearing parts, such as roof trusses, bearing walls, beams and foundations, that affects their load-bearing function enough to materially affect safetyThe builder in years 1 and 2, the insurer in years 3 to 10

D.R. Horton, Limited Warranty booklet, Residential Warranty Company form 319 (Rev. 7/25), linked from D.R. Horton's documents and guides page, checked October 28, 2026. Earlier homes may have been sold with an earlier edition; ask the seller for the booklet that came with the house.

Three points in that booklet matter to a resale buyer. First, the warranty transfers automatically to later owners during its ten-year term, except after a foreclosure, which voids it. Second, the ten-year coverage is narrow: the booklet lists stucco, roof shingles and sheathing, drywall, windows and the mechanical systems as items with no "major structural defect" potential. Third, repairs do not extend the coverage periods. On the tax roll, 2,162 of Waterleigh's 2,377 homes were built in 2017 or later, so most are still inside a ten-year structural term counted from the original closing; the one-year and two-year tiers have ended for every home except the newest.

For Lennar, KB Home, M/I Homes, Beazer, K. Hovnanian, Ryland and CalAtlantic homes, we did not find the warranty booklets published by the builders for the years these homes were sold, so we do not describe them. Ask the seller for the original warranty booklet and enrollment confirmation, and ask the builder whether any coverage remains and whether it transfers to you.

A newer law does not help with these homes. Since July 1, 2025, section 553.837 has required builders to warrant a newly constructed home for one year against defects that cause a material violation of the Florida Building Code, and that warranty must follow the home to a new owner during the year. It applies to homes that have not been previously occupied, so it does not cover a 2010s resale.

Construction defects: the 7-year limit and the notice process

Outside a written warranty, a buyer's rights against a builder for a defect come from Florida law, and the deadlines are tighter than many owners expect.

RuleWhat it saysSource
Statute of reposeA suit founded on the design, planning or construction of an improvement to real property must be started within 7 years after the certificate of occupancy (or temporary certificate or certificate of completion), whichever is earliest, even for a hidden defect found later. Warranty repairs do not extend it.Section 95.11(3)(b), Florida Statutes
The 2023 changeCut the limit from 10 years to 7 and started the clock at the earliest of those dates instead of the latest. Effective April 13, 2023, for suits filed on or after that date; claims cut off by the change had until July 1, 2024.Chapter 2023-22, Laws of Florida
Notice before suingThe owner must serve a written notice of claim describing each defect at least 60 days before filing suit (120 days for an association of more than 20 parcels). The builder may inspect within 30 days and must answer in writing within 45 days, offering to repair, to pay, or disputing the claim.Section 558.004
Notice does not stop the 7-year clockA chapter 558 notice tolls the statute of limitations but not the statute of repose.Section 558.004(1)(d) and (10)
Building code claimsA person damaged by a material violation of the Florida Building Code may sue the person who committed it, but not if the work was permitted, approved and passed inspection, unless that person knew or should have known of the violation.Section 553.84

Florida Statutes sections 95.11, 553.84, 553.837 and 558.004 (2026 and 2025 Florida Statutes, Florida Senate) and Chapter 2023-22, Laws of Florida, checked October 28, 2026. General information, not legal advice.

The certificate of occupancy date controls, not the year on the tax roll, but the build year is a close guide. As of October 2026, by build year:

CommunityBuilt 2018 or earlier: 7 years have passedBuilt 2019: passing during 2026Built 2020 or later: still inside 7 years
Summerlake1,383491
Hickory Hammock46898
Waterleigh6532171,507
Storey Grove215141532

Florida Department of Revenue 2026 tax roll, year built, as a stand-in for the certificate of occupancy date. Get the actual certificate date from the permit record for a specific home.

The practical meaning: for almost every home in Summerlake and Hickory Hammock, a defect you discover after closing is your cost to fix, not the builder's, unless a written warranty still covers it. In Waterleigh and Storey Grove, most homes are still inside the 7 years, but the window is closing a year at a time. If an inspection finds something that looks like a construction defect, such as water behind stucco or a structural crack, talk to a Florida construction attorney before the inspection period ends, while you can still negotiate with the seller.

The CDD: check the tax bill, not the brochure

A community development district (CDD) is a special district that can borrow through bonds for roads, drainage or amenities and charge owners yearly assessments on the property tax bill. Our guide to HOA dues and CDD fees explains how they work. For these four communities, the records say:

CommunityOrange County parcel recordsState list of active districts (October 14, 2026)CDD charge on 2026 tax records we checked
WaterleighNo CDD on any of 2,377 homesNoneNone
SummerlakeNo CDD on any of 1,433 homesNoneNone
Storey GroveNo CDD on any of 888 homesNone (the "Storey" districts on the list belong to the City of Orlando)None
Hickory HammockEvery Hickory Hammock parcel tagged "Hickory Hammock Community Development District" (557 parcels)Not listedNone

Orange County GIS Parcels layer (CDD field) and Community Development Districts layer, checked October 28, 2026; Florida Department of Commerce, Official List of Special Districts, as downloaded October 14, 2026; Orange County Property Appraiser non-ad valorem records for sample homes, checked October 15, 2026, and for six Hickory Hammock homes in five phases, tax years 2024 to 2026, checked October 28, 2026.

Hickory Hammock is the one to understand. Orange County's map of districts still shows a Hickory Hammock CDD, created by City of Winter Garden Ordinance 06-20 in 2006 and covering about 381 acres, and the county's parcel layer still carries its name on every Hickory Hammock parcel. But the state's official list of active special districts did not include it in October 2026, and the 2024, 2025 and 2026 tax records we checked for six homes in five of its phases carry no CDD charge, or any other non-ad valorem charge. We found no district website, budget or bond documents, and we could not confirm whether, or when, the district was formally dissolved. For a buyer, the test is the bill: the non-ad valorem section of the current tax bill lists every special assessment the home actually pays.

A seller's disclosure about a CDD is not guaranteed on a resale. Florida's CDD disclosure, in section 190.048, applies to the first sale of a home, usually the builder's contract, so on a resale read the tax bill yourself. The homeowners association is separate: none of these communities' associations publishes its dues, so get the HOA disclosure summary the seller must give you under section 720.401 before you sign.

A checklist for a 2010s builder resale

Ask or checkWhyWhere
Who built it, and when the certificate of occupancy was issuedIdentifies the warranty program and starts the 7-year clockProperty Appraiser sales history; county or city permit record
The roof permit historySets the roof's age for insuranceOrange County Fast Track, or City of Winter Garden for Hickory Hammock
4-point and wind mitigation reportsInsurer needs them; wind features lower the premiumThe seller, or a new inspection
The original warranty booklet and enrollmentShows what coverage remains and whether it transferredThe seller; the builder's warranty department
Stucco cracks, stains and window sealsWater behind stucco is the costly hidden defectGeneral inspection; moisture testing if there are signs
Non-ad valorem part of the tax billShows any CDD or other special assessmentOrange County Tax Collector
HOA disclosure summary and architectural rulesDues, and approval rules for a roof or exterior paintThe seller and the association

Frequently asked questions

Does a builder warranty transfer when I buy a resale?

It depends on the builder and the booklet. D.R. Horton's current booklet transfers automatically to later owners during its ten-year term unless there was a foreclosure. For other builders, ask for the original booklet and confirm with the builder.

How long do I have to sue a builder for a construction defect in Florida?

Generally no more than 7 years after the certificate of occupancy, under section 95.11(3)(b), even for a hidden defect, and you must first serve a chapter 558 notice. Ask a Florida attorney about a specific claim.

Will my insurer make me replace a 10-year-old roof?

Not for age alone. Florida law bars an insurer from refusing a policy only because a roof is under 15 years old, though it can still decline a roof in poor condition.

Do Waterleigh, Summerlake or Storey Grove have a CDD?

No. County parcel records list no CDD for any home in them, and the state's list has none. Hickory Hammock's parcels still carry a CDD name in county records, but no CDD charge appeared on the 2024 to 2026 records we checked.

Is stucco cracking covered by a builder warranty?

Usually only early on. D.R. Horton's booklet covers stucco cracks wider than 1/8 inch in the first year and does not treat stucco as structural.

Looking at a 2010s home in Horizon West or Winter Garden? We can pull its builder, permit history and tax bill before you write an offer, and line up the inspections. See how we help buyers or call Infinity Realty Group, LLC at 407-234-2256.

This guide is general information, not legal, insurance or engineering advice. Warranty terms differ by builder and year, statutes change, and a specific defect question belongs with a Florida construction attorney. Confirm roof, permit, CDD and association facts for a specific home.

Sources: Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 Orange County tax roll via the Florida Geographic Information Office (year built, homes; checked October 28, 2026); Orange County GIS, AGOL Open Data map service, Subdivision, Parcels and Community Development Districts layers (checked October 28, 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser, sales histories of sampled homes and 2024 to 2026 non-ad valorem records (checked October 28, 2026) and 2026 parcel records (checked October 15, 2026); Florida Department of Commerce, Official List of Special Districts (October 14, 2026); Florida Statutes sections 95.11, 190.048, 468.8311, 553.837, 553.84, 553.844, 558.004, 627.7011 and 720.401, and Chapters 2023-22 and 2024-95, Laws of Florida (checked October 28, 2026); Florida Building Code, Residential, 8th Edition (2023), section R703.7 (checked October 28, 2026); D.R. Horton, Limited Warranty booklet (Residential Warranty Company form 319, Rev. 7/25) and Waterleigh community page (checked October 28, 2026); Summerlake Community Association, Amended Community Standards of September 25, 2024 (checked October 28, 2026).